YANDELL on Spasmodic Cholera. 25
nied by those acquainted with the uncertainty of medicine;
nevertheless, it is unphilosophical to assign more causes for an
effect than are sufficient to explain it. Cholera has uniform-
ly exhibited this diversity of violence, and if such an explana-
tion holds good in reference to the disease in Lexington, it
must apply to the otherplaces whichit has desolated. We must
believe then, that it was more fatal in New York than in Phil-
adelphia, because the physicians of the former city either reli-
ed too much upon some favorite remedies, or rejected others of
equal efficacy. And Louisville, thus, must claim to have a more
judicious, or skilful Faculty than her neighbor Cincinnati.
This may even all be true, but it is not very plausible.
In the same town, some districts are affected more serious-
ly than others. My own neighborhood, during the preva-
lence of the epidemic, furnished much less than its average
of fatal cases. Of more than twenty families, containing not
less than 200 members, many of whom were considered fa-
vorable subjects for the disease, only four persons died. It
would be as illogical, as I am persuaded it would be unjust, for
the physician of this neighborhood to claim for the skill of
his treatment this remarkable success.
But the most conclusive evidence is the testimony of intel-
ligent medical men who have had intercourse with the dis-
ease in more places than one. Dr. Pawling found it much
less intractable in Harrodsburg than in this place. A small-
er proportion of cases was of the class which hasten so rapid-
ly into collapse, and hence the success of his remedies was
greater. Other physicians have experienced the same, dur-
ing the present season.
Finally, cholera was a manageable disease in Lexington.
The fatality truly was great, but not greater, in proportion to
the number of cases, than it has been elsewhere. When
met with proper remedies in its early stage, where the con-
stitution was not worn out by age or disease, it yielded with
as much uniformity as other violent disorders-more prompt-
ly, and with more uniformity, perhaps, than bilious fever,
taken at the same period. The rate of its mortality was fear-