xt73bk16mf8w_332 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/mets.xml https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14.dao.xml unknown 35 Cubic Feet 77 boxes archival material 51w14 English University of Kentucky Copyright has not been assigned to the University of Kentucky.  Contact the Special Collections Research Center for information regarding rights and use of this collection. Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company and Lexington and Eastern Railway Company records Railroads -- Appalachian Region -- History. Railroads -- Kentucky -- History. [258g] Crawford v. L&E, Lee Circuit Court text [258g] Crawford v. L&E, Lee Circuit Court 2016 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14/Box_33/Folder_4/0539.pdf section false xt73bk16mf8w_332 xt73bk16mf8w grawford v. T. 84 :3. :5:. 3.. co. 1’
Y i1181'ch 38th, 1911.
‘ Judge G. W. Gou11ey,
Beattyville, Ky.
Dear Sir:-
In LHW Crawforﬁ case yam "111 519389 aux on mha following
"itn@RRQS, *home uddreeges are 28 near as i can locate than inﬂi-
~ cataﬁ. ET Lhere 1% any mistake in aha resiﬁence you Till please,
0? course, wee thvt the mubpvenas 3?? 139386 mu 1&8 BTOyET aoumty:
C. B. Waller, T91165a.
, William JOEQQ, Jackson. .
Jease Greer, T911653.
C. E. Yilliams, Lexington.
Dr. 3. E. Johnaon, Tallega.
William Gabbard, Aﬂhol.
If you $111 send surpoanas for the Lexinbtan and Jae aon
Witnesgws to L1. kcBomell at Lexington he will hﬁVG than Lo accept
nerﬁice.
1 am not aura whether an crack was evor enzareﬂ in this
#338 ?0r 3 3hy81021 Examination, rut if tut will you gleaga have it
(31058. -
Also adviaa we as to What, 1? any, rulints hﬁve 1een urde
upon the pleadings.
Yowrs very truly,
ESJ/CCP.

 OFFICE CLERK C/OURT OF APPEALS
. V ‘/ , 1” I _
‘ ﬂ; _ ,- / ZE, ,.
‘5 Frankfort, KyLi/{i/ J //’// "W19I’Im
Deer;§ir:- .327 /’
II/m>ygur”trgps9ript of the ;ééord in ;he case's;
/__E,L_ 71,1, / {/ / _V S. @%( (//_;/
received and’filed, and tax ﬁgid. ‘
/ / This case is set for hearing on the .
E / / __,day of%§~/i_wvﬂ 191 /I
’ it is the duty offt_exappellant to file his
brief twenty days prio /to the day the case is set
for hearing, and the a pellee to file his brief
ten days prior to that time.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT L. GREENE, C. C. A.

 k; i e imrca'mx, :.i;;;::;:_._:;;;;::. W“!
\1 ; .. 4, l
j 7 A1,: viif:5;:.31:i;':‘i'i:;:t.:;7:‘:i:::':;zj?
g LW_;__;AV--;,,,;J
577/ “~ /? ~\
X ._ O W
; égz m ' / "
/ r/ ,
k

 ”R: 6’ /
.wﬁx/ .f Winiheeter, Ky., Novewber 20th, 1911.
? '1
LE. Sahuel Hurst, 4 E
Beattyvillo, Ky. :

Settle Crawford case up to $1,500.00 if you can do so at
once, wiring we today. If you can't settle wire whether the con—
dition of the docket is such as to justi y my coming tonorrow rorning
instead of tonight. Wire answer.

3. S. Jouett.
DeaJ\Head.

 N »,. ff: Became}? l, 1911.
FL; S..Touatt, Attrﬁrnwy‘ , " \
Baattyvilla, Ky‘. .

. Your talagrzm (:3? this; (ii-MW}. I rathnzxrr think
seti'immtnt on 1:.-L431}; yum; .saugganﬁ will ”are: safest course to tak8. Do as
you think ':mat min on"; it. ,

B. I). Warfiald. ‘
Copy by mail.
.

 N» V- .

Louieville, Fig.7.. lZ/l/ll. .

E S Jouett,

Your televrem of thiS date.- I rather think settlement on I

basis: you eurweet will be sai‘eeet cows-rec to take. Do as i

you think best about it. .

13 D 1"." arf'iclfi 1.‘-306?}.I ~
/

 .I ‘L. ' 7 ”_‘,LLQM-u.
:’4, ‘ V17 3"":
.,'ﬂmnw ﬂiuﬁ ﬁﬁﬂuuirl - ft“; 7!? 93 O ‘M' » r,
1 ~ 0 \ ;‘T ¥ ”Han“? S ; ‘ .. ,I ‘ 1
\: ﬁumy ut -um .. g n, ,.‘ ,,_} . f; ._ ‘ i
45.6 KY.BU‘LD|NG 1 49 ' '5. _V‘ i
‘ , .\ , 33 V . g , 3
wraitnnilln ql‘h‘niurlm - ‘x -. . - ' N nng ___; 1:“?
— ' , J3 :wa
‘/
’ , . , .,

 -

 ‘ F 52 25m. 9-‘11. C. P. B. ‘ ‘ L
. THE - LEXINGTON 8: EASTERH TELEGRAPH LINE. ' -
.4.» ' , ‘ w. A. McDowELL, General Manager. '
‘ HECEIVER’S No. ‘ ‘ TIME FILED _ I - . CHECK
SEND Bizaiwﬁwak'é‘éx5.55.?HEASRUEBLESJEE‘3 2253533} ‘ , ';;,_.Q‘, _____%__E 191..“
K3,)- 1/ » >4; - 1% TO_ ‘:I:;::;::;’y‘::%fiil'T,‘L.Zi7:'.i.’..f_f "':iif'.'.-"i—."'i‘;—“"W __,. * f‘—""”-—
:’d‘é;~;>—if——‘—‘%;::;—_':lvf:—rr—w;77" V.. W, 7A;'77ﬁﬁAWAMA7h_m_———7 7":::;;L:ir—LL'-».:;iﬁ':'—i""’-" “"“"l7—_—.——.———__“7'A7""“~""'H7 4.1;?"er
I .1 . I l 1., .. v
' >~ . i "" "m"! "““AvAW ‘1_H_—!—H—w—~———[ ..__“... "“ ‘
. . .... 7 7 if i, ...,. ‘,,A, W ,, , , .. ,, ..., i; __"Ei.._..m.._ ___.‘7 N. ,_ . ‘ . .. #.. :1.—.‘.,,,“:i— ., , .
1 . .~,:.\w‘--‘-:‘ t .
» v .,,,, ' " ' ,.,._ " a ”"A ‘ "“"" _._—__‘“... 7 ‘* -, _ . , .:. "" *—¥ ——-
x . ‘ g ‘ V '
".‘ .. .#. . , _....AE!__.~__H___-_-. _.thfWEJWMMWA
' l . 1 ./ ‘ ,
ﬁfA~ Irv", ,,, WW, TA_..__.;_____..____i__._______—‘:_—_____________.___*___.____'_4___
WREAD THE NQTICE AND AGREEMENT ON EAcKrau ' . _.

 v ‘,I
‘ I
.
LEXINGTON & EASTERN TELEGRAPH LINE.
This is a private Line, maintained by the Lexington & Eastern Railway Company, solely for its > V
own use in_tlie'0peratio,i of its Railroad, and not to do :1 telegraph business for the public. But-for
the convenieiicepf its patrons upon those parts of its rotid not reached by any other telegraph line.
said Company will, when it can do so Without detriment to its own business, receive and send
COMMERCIAL MESSAGES UPON THE FOLLOWING TERMS, AND NOT OTHERWISE, VIZ
- It is agreed between the sender of the following message and said Company, that said Company
shall not be liable for mistakes or delays in the transmission or delivery of any iiiesszige, whether linpCil-
ing by negligence of its servants or otherwise, beyond the amount received for sending the same; nor
in any ‘ease for delays arising from unavoidable interruption of the workings of its Lino. or from its
wire being crowded With its own or other business, or for errors in cipher or obscure int-ssuges, or for
delay '11] delivery ‘or for 1101]»thllVQl'y of any message unless coiled {or after its reception at the ofﬁce _
to which it was directed to be sent during the business hours of said ofﬁce and while said olliee was
‘ .open 1:01' bustiiess. it being understood that said Company does not employ messengers and undertakes
to deliver messages only when called for at the proper ofﬁces in business hours, and when such ofﬁces
are open for busuiess.
And said Company is hereby made the agent of the sender, without liability, to forward any message
over the lines of anypther company when necessary to reach its destination. . .
. Said Company mll not _be liable for damages in any case where the claim is not presented in writing
Within Sixty days after sending the message.
W. A. MCDOWELL,
General Manager.
‘

 , 0 ,l .
i‘ I 1 v / l
\ ‘ l / (
‘ k( / ‘ 4 I
_ a , .. ,- /.
. ‘ , / K
[,1/ /
' /,/
’1
ﬂ/N N // //
‘
’3' ./ ’ /
.1 / 5 ' .,.
.-,.-.. -- . ~—-._.....-v._ . ___.....___..___._......___..__._-._ ___‘N
N".."-"' .' 4' "j ‘ "‘.““ T'wM-W}
V.‘: . ‘ . . ..4, _.4 .J.',
.,...-....mw...» .. -- _-... .._ -.‘..—..._..-.m_
..7 .-v . J.., .n-1 ...v‘ " .1/1
.J.. -' .‘./'.. \.i;11 '..L). *«‘-‘1:'1\:'c
.'.. '.NH.‘ .1'11‘ 1: .":}. » 1'3. N‘ ' ‘ '1. W". '... 1N? N713. ,"'.i.1’.r'.”..‘.Nf ,
. . N . . . . . .. .
,...,1 ..., __ ., .. .,. ,- .,_ . . .. .._. ”_.‘
-‘.'1.>‘.!4 .- . x. y - . ' ' . 1. 7 , " . '1
1,. 7, , . ..: u , ‘ 1 , '1:/:7.“
* ' . . ' _.. N" . N I"
... . .‘. , .,
-‘ 1: 1' s . \J 1‘ ~‘ 9 ' 1' “‘9
- .. , W . .. ..
,. > .1 .: a N: e a ‘ g 4 a ‘ U
.'. ~- )J'H“ ').- e ' c 1 n- o .1,.’:..
-. - ,.. 1, '.' - a 1 . ‘ ». l . . . ... ~‘. g I 1. .
2..., .11-1». .“: . \ . 1. . '_‘ 7 .1 -:
44.1,. ‘ I t ... ‘ .5 l v .‘ .. i
"3*! _ ... . . .,.‘ ‘ . -. .’
...L 19.24. 1)., '.1, 1.:. _ .‘.-c
..J.‘.) .’.. ...' . , .1 , . .
N?‘ - w.- .-. . 3*. N ‘N " . -' ' .3- 1
... l\-~l.-‘ 4,. .., , ,-_.K._,1 ., 1 ,1 ..>‘ a 1 . .« .."-1‘1
~- ' .4,..35 _. 3 . .44" -,-- ‘t-i“
..C».1...“1J.,, ‘..L ~‘ '. ‘.'e - ..‘ ‘ ‘.-) ..I. 1%} v J-I.
N? . ' ... ‘ ,.... N .‘ ' .'\ N N , ' N ‘
ﬂy. .‘ .. .1 . . I .. ‘.. . x'
v .1 .. . . .- . 1 . . v a o
' “..,.,“ 1..... .. .. ._
1.:. W '.1- .w. (' .,.
4 .: -._ .4. . .1 1‘...
4;, . . ... ‘13., .. L».,r.,.1,v_ .
3" ‘4‘ . , .I.-...“— ’— 3 ' » ‘g .. .. . _ '- --!\|': a - _".- ." «N3 r'= X', 41‘“
1.. ...1.'.'..../...--; . ..,, .,.1... ._ _. . '.‘. '... 1. _. ,1. ’ .'..1. _.\1,...=,_.‘)
... ~ --.... .,.... ,1 . r- . . " ., . ,, ' ... . . .:‘ ,.. ,, . .. ,-.-.. \ .'.-
... ..1 {Li 'J'tu 1. .. . . .. ..‘ -2 - .. ,1 1 . ». .. x. ..',‘U‘ .* _‘ 2H. .\ (..' . 2.1.1.4.. 0.;
'5' 3-1 -. '1 ':?'r" .'1"."."."".‘ rx- ‘ 'N g "N: J r1 N W11." 1‘ ...', 1 mwz-a “_1 1’ »‘ N, -r,~
. , - ‘ 1 9 ~1.J_\1 ~'. ... ..,, .1 ‘...-r .,_ 9 .. - 3 ..Av“l. . _. ’ -1 .1 . . ..:;
..V.- 1... " .' 1'1- " . ,- ‘l J-
'>.',-'.’.. ".‘. 12?." _ '..4."1..4.

 .
‘\
_., ,,. .‘ . . ‘...
. . > . 4 .,.
ﬂaunt... “.....mm.-. w.....w.5.....u.» ......w...-...m........u
..‘ 4. ._ J, 3... .4, .,..
.‘.. 4 - .:4. 4...; .‘4 ....;,1.,
T - «I .':-‘4. « 4’ - 4544.444.‘-.\ ‘ 4."' ',- . 1 .3 3 . , .4 4.;-5444.1: 5 .3_...143- 44—. ,44.4\,4
... . .. 4 ... , .. ~¢ ‘., ~ ._.J‘..A, l. ..5, . -.’
. . .. . . , . . . . . ..V ,,
4., _r.._ .. ‘ 4.' ,4. . 1. 4 1h 1 '9 , '_ '-‘
., . ». 1 . , 4. J
..._. ,.... ... ,_ . , .. .. . . .J.“
... . a ' 4 ' ..4, q A ~ .0
'_ wt.“ «.,- l .., -_,. - ' _. >711!”
. I 4 .4 g. .. - ,._v . .3 , c
n 4 .4. ..4. . .5 ‘ a ,‘ a .. ' 4 ., o 4‘." e
p- 1 »’.. , ..»5.. .1 '.._., . ': “\.’ . .44.~.
,. ., 4 A» 1:1 '.4 43 . .. .1 4‘. v. :1...
.. ,.,.. . '.‘ _ , . -. .._ ,,. .‘. . ”.'_
____ ., 4 . ..4.» . . .4 4‘ ,’n :.2.."
._ .‘ .. . . 3... .4 y /- . . ' I
.. ,. ..‘... ,. . .
.4-, .- .' .' ' ‘.‘ u '4 c.
.. . c ‘.4 . .4 :.. - ' g L 41 4.'5
4‘- - 4;; . rs ' ' 4.. - ' .; 4 .‘ ~ I u 4 :14
~’. " .. 3 .. I , ~ 5 _ , -. ..”.
\ .». . s . 5 v‘
.‘.1 . '4‘4 ..'.. - 4.41; . L' n , {4; - .9
.5 . . a . . . 9 .. l, 34.34.
=40 “All”... ..‘k ..,. ., ».'c
, .». .. _ . .‘ .‘ . ' . .:,.
’.'. -' . 4' 1._; .‘, ).£‘.n
0 . ' =0 3 '9 7‘ 4 * ‘- '—4,
. ... 4- 4 .4 - v. . ..’!
, ,. ., . . . _ . . . . ... . .. 4.‘r'- .3 ... ‘. .,‘. .J.”... W
, , ,. . , , 4 . . 4 » .. -
. . _ ‘ ‘4 ' ’ . .', J ’. ' . ' '..‘ . ' ., . _ ', '4—u
., 4 . ' . J . . . ' » . '.Y .' b
. 4., .0
.

 k
' 2 FOINTS AED AUTHORITIES.

I. Statemrnt of Case.

2. Miseonﬂuct of Attorney for Appellee on three several ocea-
sions, treated resooetively unﬁer the heaﬁings, A, B, and C.
Turpin v. Commonwealﬁh, 140 Ky. 294.

Davis v. Brown, 98 Ky. 475.

L. & H. K. R. Co. v. Payne, 158 Ky. 274.

Murphy's Executor V. Hoglanﬁ, 29 8.7. 505.

Aédress of Hon. John B. Baskin, President of Ky. State
Bar Aegoeiation, ?roeee&ings of lﬂlﬁ.

Kigmore on ﬂvidonco, See. 1806.

Cook v. Comﬁonwealth, 86 Ky. 665.

Bates v. Commonwealth, 15 Ky. law LSD. 152.

Heﬂenry Coal Co. v. Sheﬂdon, 98 Ky. 68?.

Howayd v. Commonwealth, 110 Ky. 356.

5. Excessive Damages.

4. misconduct of Juror.

5. Instrueﬁion Ho. 1, given by the Court, was confused, mis-
leading and erroneous. Insofar as it unaertakee to ﬁre-
sewibe ﬁhe measure of damages, the error of the Court,
in this Instruction, was highly yrejuﬂieial to Apaellant.
Blue Grass Traction Co. v. Ingles, 1&0 Ky., 488; 3.0.
South Oovington & C. St. 33.00. v. Geis, Ky.‘72~;

3.0. 125 S.V. 506.
Town of Belieview v. Rnglanﬁ, 118 S.W. 994;
Lexington y 00. v. Brit’sonJ3 9 7:53.676; $3.0. 13./:.- .2 295.
I) o '.": h a :1» u .‘.:. a CO o s‘.'". PORTCLI', 3. pl 5: 0 ‘~‘: I: 1C)5'7;
Lexington Railway Co. v. Herring, 06 S. W. 558, 563.
Southern ﬁg. Go. in Ky. v. Uoéﬂsrﬂ,/l/Kya57$7; 3.0.

89 3.9. 675, 678.
Broadway Cool Hining Co. v. Doutharﬂ, 144 Ky. 453;

8.0. 159 S.U. 747, 749.

 21.
\\'
through collusion with a juror, coupled with bribery, is not only
sufficient but makes it the duty of the Court to set aside the
verdict and grant a new trial. If such practices are nermitted,
there can be no justice and obtaining verdicts would descend to
the level of barter in the market-place.

The affidavit of the juryr, G. F. Zion, discloses the feet
that both the juror in question, Sherman Rapier, and his father,
Samuel Napier, stood out for a verdict of $5,000.00, and that after
the jury reported to the Court that a verdict could not be reached
and the Court directed the jury to 50 back to the jury room, the
juror, Chermon Hepier, after their return to the jury room stated
that he would agree to a verdict of $5285.00, but that he would not
agree to a smaller verdict, and that, if the jury did not agree to
that in a short time, he would not agree to so small a verdict.
Acting under this lash, a sufficient number agreed to this verdict, I
but lamucl Napier, the father, stood out for $5,000.00 and refused
to sign the verdict. This shows that acting in conformity with
his agreement with appellcc, the juror, i5h(—3rman denier, took the ‘
lead for a high verdict and fought the amount as high as he could
all through the deliberations of the jury and, by his insistence,
caused the verdict to be reached for on amount that is palpably
excessive.

msr—zuerrom no. 1, crvru BY our: (tour, '
‘.’XAS COEF'UEgé Emil STL’TJ‘zEIEIG £1ij ‘:'iliE-IOIITTOUS;

INSOFER AS IT UhhthrAKRS T0 WRESCTIBh TE?
TTAWRROFDﬁhﬂﬁ,TﬂﬁfmmROFEW‘CmmT 0
IN THIS IHVTEUCTIGH WAS HICKTY ?RVJUDICIAL

T0 A???71AHT.

 00
1114.
x
. .. - . - --.3. 1.... .-. .H .m. .. 1. - ...- .1..-,., w
Awaitent 110..., c<.::_1_;¢3_:..3.311‘. 0.1. ..::9. 9:301“ in Ins;......"uc...:..,;.n .10. 1,
..‘-.. ,. ‘ .-. g. ...1. ,'I.‘ :... 'Y‘ .,. , L.‘.,- ,... -. ,».- .. 1..,,. r: ,... 1 r .’.‘
.:...»012. 23,7 he {".‘-0mg. 5.21.2... “““’GW)‘; ..‘».me...r7:; on. _.J. .301; '7..) .:.:u M; 0:.
.13. " * .2 1 J-. .., .
one accord. am; ...1»; 19. $1030 ’..’O.CG.{:: -
" r1 «.~- . -. .»1... M. .2 .._. 2.-. 4. '." 2. z '
"1. .:.ize Umurt 3.11:;....1.e»..:. .,.-e 3115;; “be... 1.1. shay 3...-.113 bo-

. _- ..::- . .. v3 ..~. .. ‘ - . '1.... .~.: . ,-. .:.-4 ..4. .'..‘ 1 ,"-...n ., .1.

3.1.0'VC .:.3.‘2.1:} ..3.. "€313.17? i’Vla [EGO 1.:: {1.9.2.113 C:..:.l:fC b.0121; UPI? f:C.L!:lLf1..l‘-.b,

flrwuni’ylf-‘Lr-‘iﬁ IX. T.‘z~g'1‘-"-,w-sa1-‘ 'f\’{‘.‘.-} Y‘Tr‘. ;- r;,~.;~ﬂ‘."-¢M14‘17 '34—” Arab-3144‘: f\‘~‘,:z ﬂowvm—jx-{érg

J..-..Ws ,_;U1.5..J. - , .- run. .1 3.1." ~\...C.LO<..1.US
. ., .4.. " .’.-.. N'. .,r' .. x. ....erz ,.. . I .'1, ,... . _-. . 4.. ._ ,. 1 - ...‘: .'1; '.l.-
we .-::9 :..-;.....n. o... 01.31.: 1.4.1....7. 5.31919, ...‘..zdﬂ, :1.mo.1uw,1 am. rawmluy
.'. .,4. -...._, ., .,- ~,‘_~ - --.‘ ...'.. .1..-.9.." .. .,. ,., 'x '1 .;x J...

.:..:w 9. U3... on. 13.1.0.9 3”. ..’;n L. 3.09.0. o. 1).}.{33 on

'~ - ' <‘=..._..: .1. W. : Jr..." ;‘1. ".-.1... - ..1. .’.“. , - ,.n. ;...-mu." .1:. :7 .. _ .t‘
..3-"3.0;" f3- .=..>-LuC.=.: .LB‘. v.51!) iﬁuzm.” .. .:./1:3 ‘...z.=,-..3.D.11.1.3.3. \.;.L:.."},OL1

".~. .». .1" In «. ..._ ,~ '~ .9 ~«-«»T " .'..‘—..‘.. -..-,1 .... .- ..‘ 1 ... I 1.. 1 .. 1 .
e 0; we :.zgyyyoaxzﬁ. {.».. ,, . 01,113. 0:: 139.10. 55.13.1439. OJ: 0:." .
.I.“. ..,. _. . ....r‘ *2. .- .. ,, M. ,13 .., .1. 1.. . 1... , . . ."‘ A.‘..

«363 C..“.OJ.‘UJ.{;$O (1.1.. Cz.i.’(.¥.?.;..... 1, ..‘..'._:.L. -..;’-.-,,1~. .;C-e- £9391". ;...-20.731 0.1.. 13:13!)

. .-.1 / 'r ‘...,‘1 ‘7.. .“. .‘ .'.', ,....-m... .. 1-1;, , .3.

; ”1.9.9. (1:910, 5:3... .: 33931-91- i ..;:s_.».-u:...r.‘mq, {..:.9121ed, {3.1113,

'5 ......2 ..1 ..‘ .J.. ”_..". ~ ,'.. .'..~ ,~_ . .“‘ 1.,? ,. , .‘-..‘" “...‘-N V 7?
:3.‘.".‘..!..I?1€7 -. . I, 3.21901“: ‘..: ._' .' 9.11,”? {3.1. (PK .1. ‘..' -. --‘.;.,O . 30.’-.(.‘.\,...‘. 01.19.3919 Chit.

x . - :1 , ,. J..1 “ ~.., .:. .... ..._ “1.4- .‘=_.. . ,..... m ..‘... ' A .-.1 . ‘." '..-. - I.
:.f_{'..‘.'&7(‘.1‘, 9..: we 1:139.” .:.c:_.c..n. ..:.1<.<31 one}; 5::; :-,...r- nevi.» 2910.211,
"“(\*ftr',‘l‘: /"‘-."\ '3 '." rr'y'g (‘.’ ‘3 "hm J‘mi- 3. *1 ;”;“ I‘V-‘vr‘ '. .‘u-‘Y; 1 r‘. t‘ f‘ 7‘"; 1n '- 1']

O:I-..1...<.'. .-.:.‘.., .L.' 9.1%.]. u... .».Uu =21.1, 1:. C(..Lu Hts—...Mw "‘~'O"’“"‘*“‘Li O3.

'..' 1 .'.. .7. ;.2. . In... ~. -w -. ,"' _ .1..? .. a ,_..-._ 1.. ..'».r‘ . .. 1
Sizilﬁ §,>‘..~’*.:3|’i?‘,, x.:;:.(311 43.:..C,,; CEILJHE. ...3.“ JOL‘ DEC! ;TJ.«‘...-‘._z’7_'bl.s..é. .‘.‘.iZCI‘L

._... .33 . ..., -.,.:~« ._...”...H. “ ., .~. ,1 .r.‘ .g —. -.. .._ .‘ , . .,J. .

(11' ‘IIQJﬁE, .'...’. 57.13.17, {2:"} ‘... ‘...,] J. 1. \. ‘..‘i... -.‘.’ ,. :..-.“u‘. _¥.Z.:-L.Y.‘3.J 1.;OE.11:Cn{711.uC
’.‘ .:.. .. r.» .5..~,_.. : . .. ..r. A-.. an... J'p _~ ., '1 -~..

1-1 9m.- 3.or1:= 01. 03.920, -.- . , ..1 ...'.eocngpej . $5.00 931:: .:.-n:

1,.?“ ..1 - x 1 , ..., -. ...."x . - “’:.,LJ. ,_ .2.1. «..4», . ., 3 :.I .~.. ..
..mgegeﬂ. 9.0.1:. 17103.... .9052...s,....«.21;. 12:205.. :.s..c:._n:, .‘..'. ...3],
1 .- .;5. -._ . -.. n .4.. -. * .. ,- '1 . ‘.-. . ..'a" .'....9... w. ..1.

9.311,. also .:...)J. (213,1 -.u....:..9e 51 :.m. 110219.}, 1r ..‘ .:..Lb

97:57 I'%"L':3Tz.'.§'.“3.‘- the:r.‘ef:ton, weasel 931.;2159. , 2'2<'2:>":11;3102155
uScuwxra ~' --«~.~‘ w ~‘~ -“-" 71-; (w ‘x m“ ‘.'" .-. " .- 1‘x'1" ..‘/h F" ‘. '1' '{‘.'-\A .9 “.1‘-‘Q':~11")"“-'. ‘:‘x 4‘ "H I m
3..;75...,.£.1.;:C[11..- OJ. ......._. l;£}i....'.1/.x"_ ...Z'v' .~1twlg ;..; \.-]L(., L.‘.!) ('..:.:.1.‘..5;\L:.r..0..; O... ;le.)

. .... i A. ...,.“ .., .. .. :..1.‘ . ...,..- "» t .N .L:. .. w. . ~~ ‘1 .‘ , ‘.‘ .. 33'
“-'.3'..’C.~'.‘ (..0 f): :..:1. 17011.03“, {.1,}, (..;;1: J.;. u-Oj {3.1.1.3. ..)03..1.=‘.~m3 x3902 ..:1C
ya“: r" ’\"'x 'i'l’nu'wl' l")(“-*- '1 J v .:...,,‘_-‘) r'sc‘a “17‘ 3 -» ‘wnw-vm-s ~1’1' '"'-1 ﬁ‘w 7w". -’ -u cw “ "_' (~"\".’
(.,=,_.< f;:.-.CC* 111-....» .'.-..,»..Lﬂ J..;tl,pu.v.....,> .,.,...L f)C..:.;.;;.1:C.-‘-u/ “(..3. (‘.. .1}. £3.00! J..). play,

.. .- . ."r '. .:.-z. ..-. .. .51.. _ :.. "“' ._ .I. J. - .. 4:. .. ., :3
- 9.9. :1. 99:21.23 VILL‘.’L.5.:..J."QTT"1/-111C....‘Y. .102. go 032.0099, 1.210 {1.121 0.1,.

" ﬂ ‘\. ':~ .-.. Jn. ... w. _" 1 .' ' ..- .1.-... ‘... .'.“.u. '1 .:‘
.3.<.I,OOH.O!.~ .=.:.:;:: we“. :1;2.:..I..3_ :20 093.1: we we; m. 7.1. -J.:u. ..orr:
‘5}?‘10 c711ﬁ:‘<‘27.»’: CVzi‘i‘Wz-ztgj‘.”

rrﬂ “.,...e ~....,..~~ ,- .5 1" J..- .. .- t" .r.» .- ,~ .'4.-'1 1 s.
..;-G w‘.n..=_s..~.._u .1..-49.3.0.4). (;q}. 4 :..-1H a 03.. 0.20mi}, 3.3.. CL DOUG-
‘3 4‘: ' ' "x '1‘! . .“. ‘.r‘" . .-........,"1 ,1 1. m.— . - -.._~ " .-.-~ »‘ «.’l .'.‘ . .. ~. ‘ .;“,~r "
.)Cr .»./3., .I.‘.)-s.0, 113.3(331 M ...:;;*1..;H:m.: {:..m ...-00.193, (2:11.395: ...3 M75113
.'...‘. '. .:.ﬁ, . .,, ..2" “ ‘T v ‘3... '3 - . ’7 ‘. .... '93 ' .. '.‘“ ‘f'{" l‘.
a)» m :m. ..:.c nus». (.:.: ')zm .1.-111.1. 35m 9...qu ~.‘hn..ctk-,r—3..1.vc 01.19.51: (3 .I.:..>:>.: 10) -
.3 I. . - .. .4. - .. .9, .'. . .I. .h “1 r‘ '1, -3 .", .. .1", . .. :.s. .
-:..C. C~>fbonﬁalulml 9». who gem 0.1. «31.00 9. (..‘-mg .. :31? 21.3300 :1:)..1...-~..':.-
“1 . .., .~- . ..r- ..'.W mud-..'.“ " -. J...“ .'..5 3 ~. . ...'-..,- . .. w .. .:...1,-..__ ..1.
1.110 99:190.." 0 .110 1 0.1.1.1...2031, ..;-.rmeve...‘, M’ 51.9. .1‘-.‘. ,...zé...ezm
.'~ - r“... r'r. -. 1.. “I ~ -.. . -’ r'- ‘ .- \ .~. .~. ,,n .-‘ " '1 . .-
3.0: .2990 ..‘-.911: .1 ma, .01.}.:,..911 (. .J.r.103.:..s. «1.7215401: 01.: .mpcmn... 0.2.4.0918
J..-._.. '1.. '7‘-'... 9.., -‘ .. $1.29.!“ "2‘. ‘ -... 4. .r' . ...' '.1 .r. .I..
mam.- W 0319 .;muxon and 1.13.1.3; .1 03.19.11: (, 130.00), 15353-111; .110 .0133.

 25.
‘ I
\
Claim on ﬁhis account 9885.90, but, noverﬁheless, ihc plaintiff merc~
13 prays ”as in his *yﬁginsl anﬁ immnfca Votitiong herein mad fox the
awn of “no Tunared nnﬁ Fifﬁy T031333 in aﬂﬁiﬁion”. {?cm iocorﬂ, 3.19.)
ﬁnbmcquant amanchntS were offcroﬁ by jlaint if aaﬁ refused
Hy ﬁho ﬁgurt. By an Orﬂor ontoroa December 4, 13 T, Lowov r, §SVG
Toaoxﬂ, u. 40,) it wus agrcnﬂ ”thuﬁ héfﬁre the last term of this Couxt;
w90n a triul was haﬁ and a new tziil Qﬁuaﬁoﬁ, there was am.fmcnf a
“etit‘vn by wininﬁi?f an file in ﬁho Ewaarﬁs, inarcawinw his cﬁaim
“1.11”“.M&...w1m_u_.
33% Dr yer for ﬂamﬁacm ﬁn 510 “00.00,” 030.
x. 4 W h ' ‘ v I, ' '

Unaer ﬁne i sues made upon ﬁhcse nloaﬁingw of the ulsinﬁi”i,
tia cane was trioﬁ, anﬂ we Submit that the snm ﬂotal of til the ﬂam-
3 Ch, ﬁntﬁ gonnrcl 338 méociaE, rkich Ska pipinﬁiff 00310 43050313
9? in 0: recover maﬁa: the alTégvﬁiotm ::C ﬁrayerr of him several
:.‘ri?.=rrf~’-.ﬁ.:':.::s. n 57m S?hm‘:r_t::r:ﬁ ‘rt 9:15.22 {:.'-:2.z'>,<‘>=i>o.oo).

The aeaiionﬁ Cnﬂ injurinm can T inoﬂ n? occuxraF an ﬁhc
53? RT? of 7:3, 101“. ?hir suit wan jusﬁitutmf on the Sﬂth éqy Sf
October, 1910. Accarﬁﬁngly, there was an inﬂorvsl of as rﬁy mi:
hvutﬁh 03, to he wxmct, an inﬁoxvnl Of Chant five manbig :xd & hulf,
bcz‘ﬁ-smcx“; The (Paris's: of? She {",r?.r373..d ‘w>ixiir?nrl, iforulﬁ. 031 376;;miz 3.8 1;:u1 3.0 05f {ﬂ10_ ' c «9: ”,
ca:t*:’,7:’::?.‘::r‘ ‘.‘-3m $701?“ 3‘ 1m:?:’3;;:€zﬁ‘.ﬁ11": in ::‘cf?o:r:’3,.tzt:‘1i” '.':ha 531:0 0:77 ”1:31: "". 7'02“ "35111:: I?.El'CL7T:""‘/‘Sfﬂ., r)“ <3:<‘31‘:.:235;C,
n3 e? in To: lost ﬁiwo Uta RVPT ﬂﬂﬂﬁa

A“ .

b/ Eu Amara setiwun f nit in the Conrt'r ﬁnkﬁruatinns im the
231.5” 1; 1:231:21; no (Kiritfaim'i;5:032 :7:: J :5211. 3.1(E’C’u‘ilii'2ﬂ :30:2'~<:):1:3:":";:“.’:2-2 :-'.’<:>3: 7' 03‘s. ”Limo
suﬂ,oo~ a sakian for in nirnnnt 0f Lhe :luintiff‘s power L0 0'33 WQUTJ.
Whig ﬁibtinntinn in rvnognixcﬁ EEG mtmtcﬂ wfkh Lhe utmosﬁ c?o;2ucrs by
thiw ﬁauwﬁ in the Wr7l—caneifornd ensc of Wine Frags Traction Co "TEE
v. Tﬂglcﬁ, 140 Ty., 488; n.c. 131 F. Va SS1. Saia the Couxt, by image
Carroll, in ﬁhn Xnglas Game —

 26.
'<

" 'Lost time' as an element of damage means time that is
totally lost, due to the fact that the injured party cannot
follow any wage—earning occupation, as when he is confined to
his bed by the injuries. It is more than the impairment of the
power to earn money, as 'impsirment' implies that the injured
person can perform some service or follow some w ge—eerning
occupation, and that his ability to earn money, although reduced,
is not totally destroyed. Of course an injury not resulting
in death night totally destroy the shi ity to earn money, but this
rarely happens. It follows, therefore, that if jronerly pleaded
and supported by evidence there may be a recovery for lost time
without reference to whether the injury is permanent or temporary.
It is usually 3 claim made in addition to the amount that is asked
for the impairment of the power to earn money, and as a rule ore—
cedes the claim for impeirmont, because total disability generally

follows immediately upon the injury, while impairment of the now—

er to earn money,begins when the injured person is able in some
degree to follow a wage—earning occupation. There oumht not, of
course, to he an allowance for lost time and for impairment of
the power to earn money during the some period, as this would
allow the injured party to recover double damages. Her is it
necessary thet the inﬁuirment of the power to earn money should
he uermnnent to enable an injured uerson to ohtein conuensation
for impairment of the power to earn money. He is as much entitled
to recovery for the tentornry inpuirment of the power to earn
money as he is for the permanent imfeirment of the power to earn
money. For instance, a gorse“ may sustain injuries thet will
totally disable him from employment for say six months, and that
will pnrtially disable him from following en 0 cupetion,for, soy,
six months longer, end, if so, he is entitled to recover for the
time lost as well as for the impairment of the power to earn money
from the time he is able to earn some and until a connlcte cure
has been effected. Of course, when the injury is permanent, and
there is n permanent impuirment of the power to enrn money,
however slight it may be, there may also be a recovery for time
lost by reason of the injury, and in addition thereto for per-
manent in nirment of the newer to earn money. But when there is
a claim for special damages based on time lost, and also a claim
for partial or permanent injuries, end as a consequence impair—
ment of the ;ower to earn money for any length of time or forever,
as the case may be, the allowance for the imueirment of the
newer to earn money, Whether it be tempornry or permanent, should
begin when the allowance for lost time on account of total dise-
hility ends. This measure will give to the injured party onpor—
tunity to recover full connensntion on account of loss due to
inability to labor in whole or in wort, and is all he is entitled
to on this account, unless it is sought to recover exemplary dam—
5.136 S o

"This rule as to beginning the allowance for the imneirment
of the power to earn money at the time that the allowance for
loss of time nude, in order to prevent the assessment of double
damages, when there is a claim for lost time as well as impair-
ment, has been frequently recognized as correct by this court
in different forms of expression, although the matter may not have
been nut in the language here employed. This is illustr:ted in the
opinion in the case of L. & H. R. Co. v. Barrickmen, 104 S.V. 275,
31 Ky. Lew hep. 885. There the jury was instructed that they

 “1
n7.
.
. ". » J- ‘a-tr "5“"?!
_ "I .. f" {-7) (s 4;" 7")0 .I.. Of ‘. {I . )II-J .. . ....ﬁl ,
. . Lawn-1m wv . :;c: 0.2. . . .‘: “7
1, ,-. - -\ .",‘ m +1.10 -3 "’3 '91. [53.11. ,.; '4 ;1..~.» ' ‘ ~ .5: 1.' 1-15‘ .7 -3 n r0314? :_ 0.3.“,-
..\.3 1"!“ q ‘VVNL .1. ..v.. . .. , —--' -... . .1." n, I .. ,j-y- '1’! ,1 ((31; J L) .;.x) r ' 5
- ~’ ~ Who *‘211‘1'1W‘7, .2. 9 ~ 1. . ~ "m ..
1.. , “'. r ‘,' . ., ...... . \..u .. ' . , .1 , . '2'” . It; 1:53.-.
4? “my, 3)’; 3.‘0£.‘.$‘,O.-1. 3.» ‘ " m- ,1 (’94-,‘hﬁ'l‘. Term... u :13 1,1... ““3; J '
...... tau-‘- ‘9 ..1 y, w 1 ..1“~..',. ,.. .II n ‘.'. c , xnu... I ~ "4 ’ 1 . . ...1— ‘- .
. r Tm «a»? t 7 wo.-151‘s: no; ., QHO I __1 , 1, A." .»f <-: Hutuuvs.’ uC
{3:13 .,I. U. .' -'»-'*’ ‘ ””"' A n , A..- .. 30.3?) “703-311. 1’0 191} .1 .LL): . U _, -‘ """ . _, .. "~71
‘ “r I., ..._, (.I‘.; . (‘:"V‘ £431.37, ,1"..- _». .. -—~ I I ,‘2 - _I‘ '1‘,“ ;~ = ‘ .:-O
a, “1.' ‘3: 045; ‘rl (r .. .3- ""“‘~ ‘ ‘ " .. -. U 3 ’1 .q ..1‘ yiny-z-v!) (a (7‘ 'H (‘..L; O“ .00 {3 :3- I"; ~ “' " ' " J 1 .
' " ‘ - -«'> w T" .:4; 11.1,..__...,, ‘ ‘ 1. 1.'. . .< -... ~ ,1 ~
"WWI, 1,.1q~.a.«.7 7.5:; $0.311 1111 )1. ..k .-.. 1! 1. 3'.“ ,.. MINT”; ‘.J“ . {.11 r, (31:11:.103-1201 11;: .:-'Lo
y . v -- 1 :1 1 , - ,' ‘: 5 . _ _...“ .;,.-.» ‘* I
1 . 5 .. .. .1, '.;-.0 ~12~ tion. 5.1:. ”WV“ " a — .- ~ n (““1”“(“O, the
1. .:' :-~ "~\,": * I - .1 .‘ .;. m ' “ r .. ,.-.-y 1 fi. TI '.’ ~._: _.;,_\.5,. ., .- *~
"”111 “. ' ~.1.13.11zw(< ..‘.. 1 ~ ...‘.», 11'] y! '1. y ‘ (1: “0:.-— ‘-’ ‘ ‘ ‘-4
ka'w- " , 1 a ‘ ...I ’,w‘. ‘:‘-'3- xf COL.,.~ kw“ q _.x. ':. ,
~ I..“..—' 4?: r!‘,«"3“‘r?!'?'3 1").1; 'wv ”n.1,, ‘ :11 . ..1 «.in H1 ‘ ‘: ( 2.; NC:
11:71:33? .; 2.1.2.53 ..y W “"‘ J ‘ 1 ”w -,I.1.,_.I(.\ .r “it?” (y? (:15 171‘} 1; '._(3 £171.- zOtL... ‘~ I «1 IJI
.. ,1 .‘" ': ,.I,” {.I "1'? ~. ': '.’ .1 ) ,1. .-2 , ~' -" ~' .. ,1 .5 1 1 . . q- 5
'vw“r‘."‘3‘ (2'34 (1'; '04? {-‘O‘il‘f' ‘ ‘U ,”‘" ‘ &r r? €" 411(14‘W"3(’ﬁ‘“; (Yr—‘.- 1 " $31qu ”11C
'1‘ x '. -—'» -- . .1 . v: ‘ 1 '1 * ..‘- 11”,; -~' ... . 1.
l“ - V ,1 . m. \ yawn-n “a '1-1' ' O: ullC «4" W" ”.. 1 y .-11 ,1 ,...11. .'. z(-1 .I:-g ra'l)‘
1.17“; 3."/w: {ff-"113:2. 1..;.=C1 1.1 \..-.... I .9 ~. 1.0M am,” {053,} ‘1; L :u: 1.51.11“ ; «.ma--
1,1... .- . 1 _ *1 _I,1,,I1I —.-lI(_.I\_I _.Lﬂit 1. ,5; 1 , _. .':-va a!“
111 “it““ﬁ .:’-g“ r~1~1rju 31(1 £3151va (3‘71”: '03“ J ,, . . , . “,0... 4y. nwﬁﬁq 220313.03; .;-.Clu"
*1‘__,\.._..J:ui..z..;. L11. .1 .:. «"3”». ""5 .33-1 r35 311.3 0.1-». on} ~---v-n_ . '..
' .1 -. «a - ,.an :, :__« u... ‘ ' , . ,-.1 ...- .1...-~qu ‘
.‘:-m a", '- R") '1" .'”."117 I 31'." 5:3 ’1'“ ~ '1 ‘ J" {‘1 l I 4 ‘ q . «1 r1 n'y‘n’f‘ f‘y "‘ ('3 {3:143 .11". .5. -!—-;'w3' .1 L: _,
"""" ' C H ‘,'-1:.“ ':-,M-.. 0,3177 (q; ‘50 i} :10th 1U1nic 4- »'1‘ V “ V " ‘ "‘ , 3 I" . ..w- “amt”; (\.'?
_’.}. ,..) -: :1;!“ ', ii ; ',' "1.‘ ._L .. 441x . _. .,.1I .,.. . v,: "’3 35' '13:. “1',; Q} 9
h, . . (3,; 4.;... ,,. --~~ ._, . "w 34.! .'\.1‘ z «'1 .10 C .'. u \_, .1. ~ ,
L’.-.'. g .. ..’ O y . ._.-. “‘11, "z""-,'? , I n 31 II._ _I_ ..’..f .. .. ~ ’ .-
-~1 »n'mmn’r'i oz" 7'0“" 73037733 ”'A“” " 3" . n ' ..-. 1,...) “on C-‘v'WW'? 1112.5.“ J..
n-‘Tmuiv .e';‘1r;u—-~