xt73bk16mf8w_508 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/mets.xml https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14.dao.xml unknown 35 Cubic Feet 77 boxes archival material 51w14 English University of Kentucky Copyright has not been assigned to the University of Kentucky.  Contact the Special Collections Research Center for information regarding rights and use of this collection. Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company and Lexington and Eastern Railway Company records Railroads -- Appalachian Region -- History. Railroads -- Kentucky -- History. [356b] Clyde Dale, Administrator of Logan Smith v. L&E, Breathitt Circuit Court text [356b] Clyde Dale, Administrator of Logan Smith v. L&E, Breathitt Circuit Court 2016 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14/Box_51/Folder_2/0592.pdf section false xt73bk16mf8w_508 xt73bk16mf8w x. / J "'7” 5:‘ // j) ,' ».W'v'mw Max
v n- _ , :‘. , ’ j ,
o. H. POLLARD fl ,7! r
ATTORNEY AT LAW / 1k!
. V 7 , n V , .
J A c K s'o N," K E N T u c K v ','-v“ ,1" 'x k" .
.' v/I ,‘,. /.. . ‘ / , / ,
. ,V ,U ' , ‘2' x - , g . ’1 ‘,4.” ( ,, I”. . V v
H “P ’._4‘ n p ‘,,: - g .v I, " , _‘ , ,, A ,‘ ‘.._
‘ . x x A
. '(‘
I.
I" /
’ ’;_, w
. , . .
‘ «I
,,, / .. ‘ “I
‘ ‘ V" 3‘ . t . M v / _ . Y
A '2 ' v /
Ii I
l:
. I. ,X. \ i - . ,, .,‘
r ,. [v -y ’ ’ _1 w
J' ., ‘ -‘ ~‘ . : -‘ ,‘ : v , m . I ‘ ,‘ ' ,
.7 ‘ " \ " ‘ ' ':' " I
A -... / ’,‘. ‘ x a, » .' > . { ,
. . V ,, V .‘ ,’ ‘. ‘ f“ M r, a“, .f M : ~. . ,- ,
If ‘ > p ‘ ‘4‘.’ n I _. _. ‘ . . ‘:' / J.JJ , y“ y ‘7 fl
" ' . ,,,: , ' y , a a " -, “WM-n
7 an». : ’1’ ’ .. . v] - \ I "> ‘\ J '2 N‘ . 4‘ 1 “a. .’ ~, . ‘ 'V c
A, . . . y .- ‘ _M ‘ ‘ .,‘ ,v :.r j _ w . .:’ :~y . .A: ' ,f , » ‘. ’. .'_» ,
,. 4;,“ . A r ,., V ,4 r .,M ._ v , ‘ , «M / _ V , m , g ,.,/<94, .-' ~‘,;“9fléam___ .. 1.‘,
\M___ “_‘_‘V ,.A .‘7 .‘" I , . ' . 1” . ‘ ‘4 ,- . ..
/ , | '. , ', '~, .( ’3 , > 5 ' ‘ .V
,1 , ,r , . A,.. , r K . . , V , 1‘ , -
.. I; 1 ‘ 7”_, ',, - ,_‘- , A -; ‘. _ .3: Mr _‘_: ., 31m .
’ " /.:..., f ,u’ 1*; L? '.:A , M . s * r «x
S ' ' 1‘ , v" ‘. / ¢
JAM: .7 ' - -,‘ f,
A , / ‘r‘M" .. / 1" , ‘f‘ 19;“ * 51‘ 3 " ' ‘ ' l
[7' ~.~»..‘., ‘_') "‘ _. *y \I »‘4. I...) f ' ‘ .: .’I. ' ' f f ' ‘.‘ ‘ ;
/ ‘ 7 /" , 4 , /’ I" ,’,/r M Nz" ..V ‘ '1 ' j“ ’:- " ' ‘ "W '
\ .' ,:w l '5 ,' » f _ ’,' ’-‘ t ' K"
‘ ’:' ..4! » . ~/ " ' 4 M
v u ' i - ' ‘4 ~‘- / ‘V' ."‘ ‘2
A. . . 2. 1‘ ’ /, '. r‘ “I ( J I, _
, ,. .- , / -~ , . ,/ M... ., » .. I” 3
if .. v ’ ~ I". ”I ’ l /‘ I“ 2‘]! If ‘ //:; V "' V .
,. ._‘ . . . - y ':7 . ‘ ,’ _f
,/ ..4_ ’* V‘ f // ‘ f (’.'/\r '_’ / / L 1' . A r"\. .f’ : .1:.
~" ‘ IV " 3 v . / _« ‘ f l L . ,_ » '~-‘ '3 _ ,_ _: , ’ .
x - , " u U , ,_ _ ,‘ r’ “ 4ng .> 1”,.» 4 'J.. \ fl ‘ V »
. ,., W" ; .' ‘ ‘ ‘ , A ',,x ,_ 4; ‘ K. .. . ‘_', _
:L ”I V . ~-' A f " k J‘." ’. “~HK /~ .1 " If» x ' ‘*"
' w - -n s / ' .- . ' .1 , ' / .‘ V‘ ‘ z 4 a ‘ , w
,. . . v ~ - ”MA ..: , f M" 5 . . _ , , .l J,
‘ H ‘ ‘ ‘ ' ' A I ' “ ’1 “ / 'V' ' 1” I; 5‘ « A . iv /
,~_ ,1 W M c , . _/ v‘r ..:: ‘“ w‘ ' ,-‘ "’.,? f" r“ a, , . w,”-
, , ,g V ,‘,... : g : \. u ,. J j“ (‘..‘. , ;/ n. .
' z‘ ._: . , ”»"‘-‘1: J” «45 1 ;_ ‘, f “e "'1 ,‘ : Mr ’ ’ ' ’
' " ‘ " - _ h 5 - > ‘ _ -, '2 5 . v' ‘_‘ ~
M ‘ ‘V‘lj‘z'v: "“ .:.: .:‘ '_ _ i > > ‘,,, .4 A.'” y: £er, '1; ’5 , (‘.I . ‘ .
r f , if .1 / *‘ ' F )3" ‘“ ,/_—‘""
I, f H ‘ . N, , 3 1/ A , , j 3 2’.', .”‘ k“ . ' V . V :'.
,' . Fr" ' f/ ‘ 1' " : r' _._ I \ ,- 'f 3’» »/
1' P r‘ A A. , , . . , », , p A {.‘_f. a M-«u—“M.
"7’”“ ‘ 7.’ ' ”if v ‘ / 1w , x , so _. ; ~ ' . v.1 Aw - .271" g/ ’ ’
.J "” ’ ‘ ' Ff ‘ ‘ ’ - J ' . /
A ' A/j / ' ‘- " ,' E. r, \ . . . M 5"? u ' ',.‘ j “7‘ r V
r) .v ,1" v / . ' ‘ .»v‘ , . ~ . K ,-. ’ . '* ' M ‘
,r »‘1 A. ,I r g ' ' ' . ,«T .' ‘,. :__ _.M. A.»
,.'/h .‘. , . ‘ t / .'_- f' 4r .”' '.._ -,_ _ »‘4!” V" ‘ ?.‘ I A?“ A‘ i :5./’,.'? A. 1.‘ fl " J.V
-" * r I .. .: M ,,. w l . g’ . . 7 if " . ‘~ “' ' ,
m ,, .» M ,3 ! , ; suffivfw. . , - A, , ‘ M...
_;_,,;.,;,. ; 9 . ' ~ :35" ’ ' ; .' .=‘.» ‘ .l' .‘ -
11M" ‘ ‘ ‘ I! ‘ ’ ff . {x-+ .. r. , fl ,
. . , ""’"”“‘I-.1yL-o———" ,. x A . . ‘ ; ‘r ‘ ; . 1'" ~.— ,» .
y ’ _ . fl =.." .’,L.) , '_’, V7 , _. i. V ' l', ‘ ‘
"T,-"‘(,-\ L > '1. v ‘ ‘ I > > /. ‘ '1 R i
/ it - ' ‘ - \- / .- , , ,A . .
x ., M : ..J?
,« ,’ I //,~ 4 .' ~ '1"
b“ . / _.‘ g .,‘" a
I M . ~-;‘ g .»_-f ,7“ ' v; ‘,4-
' , x » ~~ ' , _ _ A -".-‘_ 2 -.-< , u ., -, ‘.‘— ~ ‘ r
A‘? -' .M/ y M 7,111" ,.4 r .: ~' ». A x. C“ pl?! 1' ’ 'V " ‘ ‘ r ' 7 ’ ‘
I)" ’ ‘ ' I . ,,‘7”, - Z V L .'.7 . “~ "“‘ fly'i; ‘ f? ' j = a r ’:’, ‘2.‘} ’ .-‘o
~ A: . 7;. .. , ~ ‘ ' :- " - ' *‘ ‘ _, , 7 , ._ ‘
,.1/j" ;‘ {:,,;,:..V.. I » r" M 1 ' ‘ ' ‘ V 4- vL {"‘.—‘1, v/ ’,‘ . 1‘ * ‘ 5 ~ '-
“-" v ‘ . . ' v / . v‘ \ . ~* 2 z ' ;. - r ‘,‘
J .’I j /} V, d J/J , J.‘“; 5 , 34,5. . 94. L2,“ ’ .‘:“: “‘.,‘r’. ""'bwl’ ’ t i :- .‘“ ti ' v! “ ’ ' } ' ' ' '
- , . . ”A .-.|‘ ;-' M A, I‘.} 3*} "1' ',- 1' ’ ' ‘ \ ‘ 1 A; M ‘ .an‘ , . ‘ , ‘.2:
'V’ a r" M!” ’1" .. / 4“ M . ,a ., ‘ 1.. «,3 ,V,”: "x, t. . in [X My; _.., g; y, , . -; w ydfi‘
W" "3"" V 13 '1 \/ «as: , Hm)!» “A y ...' .‘“w ‘ “5.'. ,r - '
«a «1.". M : ;r‘ ' ' ,1 I ‘ 3 ‘ .
V. . ~ .~ - .. .1 . V,, T _ ’4 . ‘ j ‘ ,,,
M/ “‘..A. n w»
'V’ ‘-" ”F- V [y « ~ 'f /7. . M ‘ :3; by, >:_ 9"” 1,4») ‘.. \.:-~"’ ‘ ’ " . A II' " ' "" . 4- 4..
1; ‘ m ,4 ‘,4-J . ; . . c x a k . . / ‘.’— ; . (
, " . - ~ . 7W? ,4. ‘3 /"“’~-" ' ‘24” *' ' I " ' »‘ ”My-«~- A .m‘ -‘ ”by 1"" - " 1
.7M: ‘ w; r " 23‘ 3 . MM ,. . , -- ' g“: #31 ' a ‘ .
, ‘ A H M A ‘ b ‘ “‘V‘ 4 . . , » . , ‘. , - I. a ‘ ; . . . u ,:.r .
v49 M b" ‘ ‘ ~ / ,,r - - ~ A, A , M v 2 M J’.,
‘:’-4 W‘— ””'7" M '~ = v , '. ,.‘» -~ - .. .,.‘ - *’ ,/ ':':rlt-fi ‘* . ‘ 111-va , ’1"- “ M
”PM"; £- k‘mimé‘yz "731.» f? K. J , - 3' 442,43" " '1: ‘ ; V1135» if]; ‘ddwl u" ,1 " x ,

 - . ‘37
o. H. POLLARD “Wm—2‘”
ATTORNEY AT LAW ..
JACKSON. KENTUC? (7 .,‘/y $2.2 , ,3 3:" ..
(2" 1 1-7' ' .2 MW" . ./' Maw-2v "
' - / ’V'- 25 " -." 1. \ZJ (..»-£23”? ‘3 3“‘

Z2" 2- 2’2" 2"» 2 23 222» 2x 2 :.1-12.11. 221 2127 2 22* 12’ 2w1 \1 11 2‘72:
j 2" (okra—“‘,. f. 2' f ,. "‘"YL‘" 412'} J 2‘ . . -

/. i3 “Y .2 r‘ I ’3 ;1 I 1 : ‘ ”1,,/2“! \w ‘2
12‘ \’ ' " V '/ ._.A 971.3 5,21". fl???» 2':? ct 3122.275“: 1‘1 ’62., J
912222-31“ 11:17 27“ 2,2/2‘:»3‘212 2'2123“-1..::1—-2~1- <3 w .1 .22! mm A323 - 2.
" ' ' ' ..;“
ML'“ ‘ ,. 1,; \ ;2' 1 ,1 KW . .. ,_,; .
' 2 .14 , A '2: (,1: «a > : #1. 1’4 'L ,r' ‘
{Q‘ \121/w .23,-"‘. 1» .. ,_,«r .1 1’ 3-22‘ 2’ 3-«2’ 32v 9 11 1’2 Ir» ‘23 ’
— 1. 1, ".2 7,227“. ‘13:“; ,3 11,111 .4‘- 1, ; .21 ., /-2 .;_“; 2 1 .1 .C7
'2. Jul/1 2’.-71;) ;2t....,m, ?l f »L.! e x. - ,4 . . , .1 / ‘V‘ 1: 5 1 ,~ “1’, / \ Mt’gi'h'fl'
P .1 / {‘:‘ .,»-7"" 1 —3 ~'2/(2221 1"! I ’ 1‘1;; 37'« ,2 1, 3 '
3 2 .- f“ ,. ..1 .7., 2‘31/ 21" ,fi *1/12! 2x":,,11./ _.v 2 '
/' 2' 2'7 .1 " 3 - 1 2 " ‘ "2 1.31221“: » (’,. / "I , ‘) ‘ r’ x- , ;. r
M ‘11.); /(.": 1” '1;/i f' ‘r (1 £41 »..,1 ;.’;w 1. , 6.. K v...» - r .7" ‘,2" ’_ ; I.“
3‘ “' ‘ ‘" " .2 r . 2:35;. .1.-14W .: »n...- 3
' ‘3’-7‘., .J' ’a "2 ' .13" it; .»‘") fr] ' ‘1 .- .'" 19'1"” "it 3” 0 /,-‘ .3.." tr 1’ \.‘” \
191,2 flm 122 < . ,1.: .2 - .11.. we:
.‘ L13" l _ 1'21 ‘ .. -1. n ;-.
._2‘ ; ".....- .g . ' _2' 24,1”. 362‘“ W “ ‘ . _
“Ty“ " 2‘ K “' 2"“ ‘ ‘ ’ ”3» .A.-2:3 f1": / 1°? 1‘ 1 ,2.?” 22' Air 1 1
e 1 1, .1 , ;2 J .‘I. 1. ,2 ;.“ A ;. <1,
,2" wer— » 1263 - / 11.11112 12 12’ K.. J <
..2' 44’...» :1 ‘ .1" 12 ‘.2“ . . 12: 2f 3'22 1:1; ‘.1
m ».‘. ,r ‘ .; // ‘ J f I 4. f ..1 g 2" ,, .~
. ‘1 rug-2' 3' ,2 .r' .;_; ,, ,,, . .. _ u 2, .6 f , .2 ( '_.,»
'.-' 1‘ ,. ; W" \I" ’ "'4 1 2’ m? _ 1, _., 2),“ ‘ ; "
e’ "fibfl 5,5 K] O } ‘ fl; » ; 1f.“ 7;.I ”fix“, j—k‘fr: . ;. ‘1" ' x '1’: .
" ' .2 ~»————3*'§:"72};:’ :‘1/€21” kit-_‘.“; ' L.- i ’ J’ *1 ;2: 3 ' c, ’_‘, J
1 _ ;: '2/7'” ,... '.,3' 1“" V: " ,_.5 ,fi'E' 11" . 5' ’.I f ..3“: .;A," .3' ':‘" ("C '2’.?
,2: 2’ ) ‘. (2‘—,2" / Q '72:: ’2 "“ 2’ ‘2 2‘” -~---~
' f?) [52" M g 2‘./2 L2" ,’/’"~'JJ3' {/1 1 "" ~‘.? I ' I §: M '25--”‘79‘31, ..:2- .;
.;_;-..;31 “’.'“ 1 . "2- .‘ :1“ ',2 If 3 ‘22 :3 u 4
*3/11” )' SD 2 _..;2' 2 ‘ .1 '2; .': \1 / 1M ,.»—“M3 2
. j- ._,;1 ;.1'; 2'21 .Uflp‘ , ,“' v ;
.- ' A 1" , .1." ..‘ ‘ ’ ,1. . , .2
7L id" . fl» 2"” '\ 1 ,' .3, 2’7 ,"’ I := ~""¥'"’f,n“."‘"; ""1" ' ' 2’"
'1" x7 I ' 7 ,f' . , ”3‘2 ALMA :..—3' 5:",3'21133“ ‘{ " .4 1 432‘ ’,_‘ffiw
,’"IE' I“ @121} fiw_-.~y .‘.‘“. 1 ;' ’.,"! 1:: ‘..“ I ‘1' 2/[4 A; [M VA > ”_2' _ i
" ‘,2-3" ..Qiyz .1 2m»- ; 213')” " 1" 1 HEW/1' 1‘ ‘.“," 5222“:.3£11\"'22" 51622“ 2' '
J 1.‘, . -, , , ‘.I}! 2' '.;; ‘,‘ ,312'/'/"* .' i' 34:“ 1 ‘2 .13
, ',1- y _As’ > 2'; ,1 13 .1 Ir “(._.‘-1» W“ v" 1, W . ..;,“
. ,1 .»»-33 22’ I ’ 3' ‘3 3' *' " ,1 / ~‘ " .12 a, 1, J; >11 A “
' /:l iii/fl" / 'M "" ' ’4‘ 3"' :m r"; 13 "21:1” " 5‘.“,.'\,u\! ’ '4'" ‘
\ x" . , 1413'!“ 115 “a 2’ ~" / _/ \.‘; 1x
WV ' . ,. V .' 111.1132 ’.2‘ 1' I‘ll-"5'"
~91! [:’Q‘ i i V 4 f If ’ “?iz‘7/WI'2' .'L’f’t’; " 5' 'L ' ‘ '4 g"
i’ 2.2“ '2 .. , . 1 / ’,2 /‘£({: r}, x? 1" <" t i f' . / .~_\\‘JI
:2 ""2" 62-222121;:1‘372 3 2' ‘ x1112 '
7;; 11: 2,2 3 3 2 ,
2 i 1' 2 ’1
..2/...’ 1 ~ - " g ~ 2 {2.22126 a x 21 ,2“ ,2 “
\.‘“, ,, 1, /—/ 1 (1’ 43‘ \1 . "4~21w“"'"' fl ’1;! £17., {2' . :.1 «(‘., . - (71> K fivfifiK-‘géw
"/ " 34 t1 “3" )74 f x 3.1221“! 1“” 2' KW“ twai‘w , - - .1 1}" I 2.13%?" 3“ (
12 1- 112 6 223-1 1 1 ”1 2 2 < < 1 2‘ We .2 1 1 «
{~23 2 ; .1 3 // , .2 //J .;va 1 -._< .932 ‘ r-
1' ‘ \ " ‘1 132"" '7‘" ' '2‘ r, V '/ '/' '.‘ . _ off" 2 ‘ 3“ ' 3"'7 ,1.
‘ 12 {FL/"2 /!3:' I «V \ ~' /» r.. ' '3 M2” fl.” ”Afr" 'l' ’ <'
WA“, ‘3 2' ‘ J a ,. J/‘ébf‘dyfiyr ""25"." r" 5.4,. 12"‘1' is“. f . _, 11 ._ t ~ I K..”? m“..-
// '1 (2,111,2«111 ':'/f .1 7%,} [WW ”':/V 1‘,-‘111—«2-212‘ _,,_ 1.11 ,1 _ 435153 J: J; .1 1“" .11.,» {2‘ r. 1.1.:
';)/{'3 " 73V? Q/ ':’}, r67" 1.2;." _f; M 41 1'.. fifi,"j,/flcg ‘1'” £224" ..: ‘ ‘ 3' t' W" ‘ ',
, 1 ’,3,‘ :_,I' :1 z- .‘2 -,(,.1 ,2 »
2" ’ " ' 112' 2’ \
.1»;. 2 W" ,,
,e‘fii‘fi' 1 i271 . ry— , 1 . V‘” «.12 22.222 - “‘. 1 22311132 '2 .1,
w" ”“""""'“" “mg-.2_; ; ‘2' ”,..1 _ 23212-212.;.mkw ‘.,; <3
' Ii" 3" ‘ 1:24:21 .1 . 2"”‘V'xh’; "' '2.“ / "Q ' " m 12‘" .. v.*'f’£'”—'¢? “'.J J": $91.91!; [':‘ ..._1.» M
, ... 1’ “J '1 " V' ,l . ." 2 I ‘V. 3' "A ,»”/“"12: ;.'/’.;,“ f W““‘n" ," ME" I" L
'2 " n1 " ; V'MV‘N“ 1 ”~:., Q52; , 5 “I" ..3“ ,--' W ’ I
.- 11222122212. /'/1r,“133'2 2' 2" " ',»" r72:1 ' 117' ‘.J} .114
I .w w “ ..,./.’.2 a; 3 1742/ .»g,.,.1.fi."«15j",. ”131122-23 "1 “122312) 1“-

 O. H. PO L LA R D g I;
A T T o R N E Y A T L A w -,»“
JACKSON, KENTUCKY
.g 7575—55-5 r ,7»;
6 ., ,., ,. .*r-f' d ’ .. ‘ ..,...734 5 [ ,.‘?" ‘. 4 _:’". .
J “1‘ ”‘.. ‘1 . :‘:,“w: ,’. ‘_ ’. [Tili'wrf'j'k ,._ _‘. III/Hf! ~ (’,. ” ’:»“ 1 . w‘” M ’:.qu- «Myifl‘zw, film
I J, ,__, V x 4 . K. m g ._.-— / I _ Z I ,4 ‘ _ ,. 1<
v .. - ,.. _. V
. L <5 [“325 #4? ,.jn- 21;. K j: i, ’10 [/l' ”.7 5 (,4
:. , ‘1, 4 - 5' j 5' ~">.u-._ .‘ «‘ ”if“. ugg, 5. .. A v, .,7 _«r . .
r A 1..-:.5 ,..-"r M! W“ *"T‘ ,7'» ; I‘ J ,’3" w: Hiram" wi‘rhww 05w 5 ..«— A/ / W"; '- a...)
TT"T;—- ./ . . .
.. x .. _4 ‘ . \, ’,. / .,_» . “:**-VA. ‘7 . "A,
3 ‘ .. “ i (f, . f ,' . (a } .- ' ‘M \x‘ ’I W ‘- 1‘ ...-w I’ 5‘ r6 '7. £7 ,4 ,4 p s -‘
r .5.
_' « . I «‘ . , “277'
F . ‘ 4“. f ,. ‘ {v / .., ~ «‘ .;'-~.», .. f 4‘ .. f
f) ‘3’ ' ”fl: .7""!- ) ..' f4" r!k.x"‘{ . , ‘| _’." ‘ " {If ‘I/ .W- 25" I ’ [Mi—",1? J
» 'r‘ ’ I'." 5“ .I' ’ {I '
\A‘.‘ ‘7‘” ’ I > . ‘7 "‘ x 1'..pn-—\>~—I . (‘,,. ‘. _ ‘ (, ,... . -; ‘; ~ ' J " ‘ . ., . ,«yj‘ , ‘ ; ..; I ,' ,., ' '
v" 5.3 2 .’ja wm‘; 5. i 3’" r’ ' “ r \w‘ f " 4 -. ‘ I“ p‘l' v" ‘ 4’ If: It 2; 746‘ _:.}; %”‘r';‘: 1 E, ‘15”, . 5,”
1 ,, in” _ (fl f?" “3,, #5.. ”‘.'... ‘ J._ . V, .
.:.M x a 7*- , .. v ‘ / ,7 Ll 1- ,2 x»’ 5 -'
.r ' \ =7 1;“ ,..
\‘.1.,. 4 4 . . . . K . [v '.’, . “ . 9 . _.
.4 ‘ .,,,..Wg- . ~/’ [13...“ :.‘/.’,,.“ ,._ ' C ..—- : , f
:‘,/7- ‘ r“ “iv . M . g 1‘ V-“N I; ‘, x '7‘: . , ‘ ' IV,“ ’.I ‘flfl,rfi5~v5 ',r'" .,,; ’; . C. \d ‘,,-i '.w-I’
/:-. {..!“ __I 1’ 4 _.: / . f l' ' 5 '7'
> .W‘:>r"7 <"'». '. 3 . .5 .
/ l .- \ p (d. V‘ .. '1 / ,‘-‘ . // :.. or]
>‘—-. ..,“ , _, 5 . ~ . . \v‘ .:m,.'. ' [-,' , ‘ «b I, [W~
. I < “ \ Q. .. ‘ ,, '5, «’ .. , K“ .47». ,.f.‘ _. ._ . .I‘ ‘
."L 4” 7,’ 4 \ fl» ' 7', -_ fix" , ,’..ol‘ 5 rim!“ (' 1' x" H ' ' 5” '54?" ,‘ . ..‘ ‘../7‘ I, .3 ." », .
/’ v 3 V I /_.. 5n. "'2"? .:’. :‘ .:‘ '
x. y ‘/ J " ‘... ,1“ 'i - 5‘ I“ 1‘7"" I; '4' ; .,',, " .... - ' ‘5' ‘7'”
,1 . ‘- 5 : . x. - ‘,,.”. w ,5 ' ~ 7 7.,...5 q r.‘ ' a ‘ .
/ f 45" ‘ . fi/j‘ ,’»; '5 2::; .- . ; r ,. "
\1_,_.,,.. -... , _ ' _ ‘I. /_ .- I .‘ . W.
..._....." r x
/ ~ g ”rub-_:.? .' / / ‘ I ’,.. ‘ .1" ,'qu ., '. 5. -’
fir I.." ' //:,"" ,‘V ,. (“5" ":' ;,.-5 ' .x ‘ .
,,.? ‘ - .. e" 5 ‘ " 5W" ”A "“ ‘ [I
.5 z, 1 5 5» . 7 -.1 \
’,,..”--_7--“....._.-”.-.1111 —J‘««~< / ’1' (,,..m .1” a, 41* 7’.-,,.”; .. jun—~-
f‘ 7 . 55 . ....~ .. .» fr .' . «. .«J 5 55' a? —; t :' I” : . «’z’: 7 ,
_ ._'. «T; ,. . . 7_5': ‘5 . I’M y ~ . * " ' .‘ 1 ~ '57
. 4 i a.- , , . , ’7 (r i i .5 I g . .«
. 7' f _ 4,5 t, _, V’ ,4,, .' F ,. . ‘,.; x ’ .x
7’ 7/ ,- x \ ~ 7‘ A ..» e ».., ,v
1‘; \ “I ‘. f I ' /‘ / ‘ <7; \M‘W‘ ” . 5 'jl- «3 ~', I-/
g"- ““.' : ' :’,,» I_. “.:'/27' '_ _,.‘f;. f. /, /‘;L_,.a~_‘/¥;//':-"b” (322,157- :.' . ',./.':;" .‘7 “ « 1.5 a" F ,1 .1: -’ ._‘ ,4
? .5 c . J" (I ‘L '7 it" ,'/' 1‘ '1'; 4’ ,4" .191“ j
5 .-‘J ~71 55... ‘ 5y" . , 4 IV???
«r -v :..-x . ., 2 - . .7 \ .~"‘54/M~~5 If”? " '“’ 47:“- NW
. , . ., as L .« T ,« / \
.5 \ j . ~~ ...» . ‘,./5 . .. . 72.5.»; .54 7>..~,57-.5«w
'- . ,1 5: . 7~7 .' {r . 6- flow. 5,, :1"/".4 ' W T ,« x 7 . I“
‘ «7a .777“; 2- - .-/ («T W , '7 r- ' //
V ‘.. ..’/if I ' *‘I 0 ‘W‘ / I: // W' ”_‘. 1' ..
. I ' m .' ‘ 5'5! ...‘ "1’ ,1 / '.r"'.‘..c'_: _ , g -' I" '3' I’ l‘
. I]. {A S; . . f)“. .,‘ Ti“; .‘,... 7 /#/ 4.1,. LC, I‘ -- 4.) / f .
5' i “ _-; 155....-.“ x" ." ’Ku --. 5.... .
.7 ‘ "M“: 'f , 9:7”? :9. j 7" f 4. ,.'! ,.' I ‘7 ~" \ép’i ; [.._.1 V 412'" - "(X ,
r 1" T’ >41: .' ’.. " ._ .,';ir‘r‘- _ ' . g1 .« . j '5':- s
/r‘ ,.’ 5 1 .‘ [f ,7 .7 ‘.‘ H. i,- . 1., ._y‘ i
, I! A w/ \ \ [VV )3... .‘. _
y . M . . 4'“. ~. ' ,.c. . ' (W2 t . -‘ f5 .
. V ‘, j, _a . . .. I ,4 _' , _ , 5‘ ' .‘,. ,7 x . p / ..- .,' 14”,, {y a ‘5 7. ‘
W: ’.’; " f" ‘ x ‘47. .,.} r’ v ‘ ‘ J 7‘" ,..»; 5‘ if" “Imm— '7‘ x mm“ " “‘4 :5 =54 Fifi/755..
'64:“ I.) f.“ , i , ' 1"” ’y V
w"? v V ' ,,. r
' x *W’ . ~ ;
a... . t. r ‘. ..4», «WT 5.
7‘" i ~ ,7‘? ‘ > ’ : /‘ , ~ .5
‘ijx . .....555- .5. “ff \ ..:.z. ..__ 443mg; r... J; 5.»- ; p; “.,:.me fry/_:. f; ..
. yr J 1‘ ,. _ ,l ”7,1,5; ““Y" (:- /) 1,,.".,.‘. .‘ :._ 2, / ..4“ : . .4. , ,4 5. ‘ ‘ . w
L ‘1' f « ’ ’,,.... ... .. IE. 3 “uh—~,— .. ,
,. f bk WK ,15 (.4»-,.'" I .. ‘,,, ..,: ‘ “:’,L ' J67; {.3 X log” 4 z 95?" (’,.-f"? .,.
/~». - ‘ TF' ,. .. , . ‘ . . ,4)..." . ‘_ ;,- J v A.." «L " .”, 0‘ 5; ‘..-":' ,. ' '.’ «r‘ ,, ' :‘A‘ “ 1. -' :y ‘...L.._
We; .,- MM "E11,..- . “a?!“ ,- #6414” y fl, L f 1" iv- 4"" . f _ r a
9 ”j? . g . : 2:.") ‘ f -
p/J V’“ 1C7” .5771? "5'5" ,7‘" " 7 f 7 M? /
. .5 ”..-... 5;: . ‘ . ‘:. /’ ‘4 . . / “fry ,1. a V3, «. .‘ ,1 “g (“’.-3,. j, . ‘ 5“ ,My
,7 L 52‘- r ,4 «’7 "(7 ‘1 " g ""‘“ 5.. ‘ ‘ 7
,~—-—-——-——.r. 5’32”“...7 _, K .,: ’I :3 {If 9,1 .3,:" 7““‘T _. / y W‘“"'” n
, i (.',, I}, ‘5 - .I’ . “:5“ if} . 1:, f. ,7 : "“:‘ X. , .’:;,“ . H '5‘;..:l’ym( 1’“ g‘,, ’_r 5, g: '.‘. C 1,. Z’V}'1 457‘»...
QM“ ., .’ ,..Iswggwex. .. .. a. 97/5“... ‘ *
« L» W . . ..2 . 2‘ z'wM $2.174 .. 4

 ’../J/yu- .‘V. 7‘
,5 $4,. ,/
‘vm,,,4,_,,...u~/ '
O. H. P O L L A R D
ATTORNEY AT LAW
JACKSON. KENrucKY ’ Cy" A V a
r“; l‘ ./ /~‘a \_ .' ’I’.....gw4... wfiwdv‘f 4 ;; // ;,.-«s n
’ V 3‘ A . V :I fir“: -, . ,J 5"; I.‘)?" ’ I 0 '.3' . ‘-._ ' . r ‘5' W _ 1 5 .
'.I ,4»}? ,. . ‘Z/JFWJ . ‘ .1 3 ‘~ (if :,:(gr': :x‘ ..5 (w {.:3 (.’2 “" W/ ’._a * " 1' .;... \
.:,: fw‘ J; In ..»" to" " ' ‘ , .' r
/ “’ ‘~ /” ., .2.
j t .m “7" 34““ 7" Q fifl-"f‘ri‘c .,..wfxf‘fzfi3.i¢%3‘""}’*<{. :.'; wt"
3 «5 .I‘ .-," J «um J ‘ ' H “ V ,’
. ..’ jw‘Q'W .v :1. 1 , /}v A.” .4_“, i -
~,I , _..-.«....a‘ , ., (.;cv‘ ‘3 ‘,. «g. in .... ‘, M~~ I
f}x‘,€f§ «‘ C“ I {I A " / ‘I': 3'30 £1 3’ _ a ,4; , ,.p'l’l fé, it}, .01..
. . ' u“ m . 3" 4. W P ‘5" _,‘.!«fifigf if},mffiy..;f...-,..g,~.ar_£~ ' t” « vr fl
3' \fl... f/ ."‘ ‘.;»:“gv‘v A; ,_.v} ".”'.I; fl/f »,.....“ ' p ...,.}? " 1.'” ' / '
I . ”':?...“ . ' '%J'~fy r ; .va iff :2 4.5"“? it" 9 r -’ _‘_
‘. $353373? JM’ (745431...“ R” /q \_ 777*”
M I \j/ "’,‘ ’ 3 WWW .-’ ., “_.‘? 1 ,i. 1.'") *:.';?.‘;-','7'k.5-?
..._...-.q-m ."‘" .. .4} ’ f‘ " I "
“‘“ .. . V . i ,.x w, (my an .«r’ e’ r
r I"
.2I ». fr? ;’ .-. , - / .t 4 . 4 «<4 « ,, v r V »-
...n ’:.,s ; «,.,._. fig; (539": "“‘, "41"” $3 .1 -.«.« « , ”I" ...4. ‘
’9 N” .‘,. ._. * _,:/.3 . ,~ . .‘:-.;...... ‘ ‘4‘ *g'
v. - I , ’,, / ’,..“ .« ’ ..'-‘ ‘1 .'_ 1.., ”M
\(r. (’.“-INI‘u/qu' «’;} ’,' 557"? ”1' I. ¢ I, l/T'v‘x {”3 N“ I’mhhwru-
" ‘ ""“ . . .4... ' fl ,_ V" . -- ’1".
44.4.4.4...”‘0 / . .. . ”iffé‘“;;/ ,. « Aw
. i 5 z/ fw' ..'..... .** 57 MN)“ ‘ . / ,4 g
-’ '2 r ““’ ‘....t‘ " ‘ ‘ u; 4. I .«—~"--- ...4.. , ..
. " .- ,.:-‘4" ””‘Ty' \ ”””’” . , fl ., ..-‘ I. f”
. .- \ ».w’ . .4 “”' 7 .« .,,!" "’.. " " ,.’ ,...-
“T? /«? ., .. .~ 4- we???“ r’ .,.’ #2“? .,.z’ u” f- N ‘~ » e
2 L ..'; ...5 .A ‘ -' u}.
.3 § .9 i. rt' i?" 3’5- W J" »"’—'_' !
W . I. v. ,’ ‘....r-“u fl __ ‘ fl _ 4'19“" If f. a
. 1 .« u _. . . "‘.»" .‘_-H (,..-r '4. .3“ ! »..
,=. ”’.L , “:’ ._.~ ‘1. x‘ ‘_‘, j ‘»:-p' I 1 4._ '.‘“ ,j «, 7 g, . 1,, . i
“‘fi’ .‘I: :.‘J .:; a: . r .J' A A" a" ,x
) » ..‘ ', ,, ..,” ,- , .1 .
w“ ‘ -- A
44......“ \:~ ..
,o 3'5“ / M « 4. s ,4"? '3’” “’" "' 3’ "’
“Jr.,-”L; , x {1.2" 1;. .. ‘3’, (x .= . ,». ..4.» ,1 « ’.1 / ,.’?
1 - ”3r ,v. 3:6 . I ,' r. 3» , _. I'I/2'“ 7’ ' .’:/2' ”a" f‘li’l v'v" ’3 m“: I?! ’I'" T; (3 ”VA/'1'”. \
J.:.. . 0 ,x v - /v" ' -
'; a z / «.“' . ' /
..»' [3‘1“ ~ / .r‘ f I ,/ /‘/« K /
A ;;/ ' ,1. . 1. £1 ,- I; M . . ,,./'__. f
l ;x :::: ’-'«'r"""’"" ',....I _ .. :v_. ‘ ' ‘,,, ‘ , g a» w
3 " .._ ,../9‘9; f/ ..L .I.. W « .~
\./I a?" ,'7 if b‘ " """ i/ .93)
_...wwww..-.4........._4.._.m44.,. ., _, 5%,. -..,.”...MV .-....M..,,4«.....4, ... ...,....“wjygw‘kfiwmaw‘m‘ .._...
M 1.»..“ . , '.. "““ 4.... A
_:« ..«w . M, . .
'I“ Is" J: . . x " .‘} M»? [iii . ..9 «\'..»“r
.« {fly (.5 '.’, M ”L", A f _.«; .13 ««‘1 . ,. - I , 3 . '
:.."..‘J‘W ..er '« I, 1W. fur" (3 4' “M “’I , . — " ~ , .. -
" V 4; 2k" ..’" 9 r t5 "" , ’ «.-‘
if“ {I I ‘

 ’.
. J / a ‘. ,v . ,4 p .. A
. ' . j r I .
._ ’,.
, . . ‘ .
, a,
. , > »’
,« ’ 4 ,., x J _ k . -
4 ; "1 ~ "

 / I
r '
\ k V
\r .'
l/ /
’L ‘ .
,
-. ' _4'
’ 1
/
/'7 / \ -, V .
. ‘ . . ,
/—-:,”“ «7,- '
. ‘
‘l
29'
,.I
,..
I
/ ’
‘ > .A ~
’\
I
,-,.-M ‘
. .r‘” ~ ' t . '
v ’ , I , . l
l x i a , :
, .: l 2 ‘ ’~ . .
. ‘.. K \ 9 i ;
‘ ." .4 l I ‘1 ‘
, r2 .. ‘ a ‘z
./ . " I -
; - i s
‘ i
A

 Vifiw{) . ‘ ._ 4 f
' .»i‘ ‘V‘ .L “' pr .? J i..~ ;
. ‘-....- :1 ‘ 1r ,_ «~ ,4 ‘,., i ( . ,‘u‘r’ .1 MA.
Breathitt Circuit Court.
Clyde Dale, Admr. Plaintiff
vs. 2 Authorities for lefendant on Motion for Peremptory
Instructions.
LexingtOn & Eastern Railway Company Defendant.
5s C.N.O. &.T.P. Ry. Co..vs..Harrod,.132 Ky. #45; 8.cm 115 S.W..699.
#10 & 0 By. Co. vs. BarnesI Admr. 132 Ky. 728; 8-0. 117 S.W- 261.
t/Conrjff vs. L.H. & St. L. Railroad 12h Ky. 763; 8.0. 99 S.W..115%. ’
Z/glankenship's Admr. vs. Norfolk & WesternRy..Cor 147 Ky. 260;
s.c. 14} S.W. 995.
i l/éggtkfetz.vs..Humphr&ys, Receiver of Wabash Railroad lhfi U.S. 418“.
i h 1 icited in many cases, see Dig. U.S. Sup. Ct. Rep. 1~206
Vol. h p. 5970).. t
I St. L. I.M. Co. vs. Mcwnirter 229 U.S. 265~5.i ”
, Under this last decision, it would seem that the Supreme
Court will, itself, examine the evidence to see whetner tnere is
any substantial evidence, under tne law as laid down by it, to
authorize a submission of the case to the jury and in considering
E . . . .. .
i this question,.it will not be goverlned by any SClntlllfl rule.
(See Improvement Comtany Vsr Munson 14 Wallace, 442 and Pleasants
:fiéyrmcj vs. Fante 2? Wallace, 1161, C _,3 j v, {’,!;,/ 1“,
iii/,.,,,“ "titresiqfix: t/i'i“."‘ii‘~}-rri ’.' . if :‘:“ if; ‘ til???» VG, /C’x9jrvfl y ’- 41:: (1‘
gag-..,, 1%»; saw; iii / ' - 1' ,..
v” AHe ton’s Adm. vs; 0 a o By. 09.. 157 Ky. 380; s.c. my“. 224...
X Wickharo vs. L a n, 1.35 Ky. 288;: 8.0. 122 s.w. 154..
k/gwann.oase, 160 Ky. 458; s.c. 169 S.W. 886.
> ) er A (Try; L
L & N vs. Johnson's Admr'x. 161 hy. 82hna¥cq /?/ a\/rj 5 . j
. ’ dwix’l ,i r
Dietirguish L 8c N vs. Lowe/T 118 Ky. 260. S/é 1} 3x ,. 7W ,s’jfim 37 ,
W“w“""’“ J S-9 "Wt/‘7 (4%: S/ii‘fdi
___>4______‘_____‘_______,_,__u_,‘_,'..,I‘i \th‘rJ-txt [7.
. {9 ; ai4nwh\xiib be
As to the necessity of pleading the prevalent use of
tracks or yards as a passway, see C & 0 vs. Dawson 167 S.W..125.
If one's death is caused solely by nis own negligence,_
he cannot recover under the state.law on tne Federal Employer 5
Liability Law..Ellis’ Admr. vs‘.L.H. & bt.L. 160 S.W..312.

 / / , ,’
I” f , / ' a f /. .
, , \ ‘_ (I r_ _,‘l ‘ A V ‘.’_'.; “~-:"
/
, ' '\'\ k ,
// 5, ,1 ‘ ‘ ) ,1 i
,‘ ‘ g , ;
b / ,‘.f '.f/ ,_ . )1 ,
a /. , . ‘ ' 7’ 4 5 IX. "":-123g.“ ,., I. fl"... \ [,4 :4 f r
.i ' ’1 7 v V” . / ,/ ..
‘7‘ ; / 4‘ 4. N, ,‘ ..‘ N , I , __/ ~ I
\ /\/C -\ ;é/f’flr/ K} (I \ ‘ I j _ ,
, j «’ , / M I ‘._»
/ x/ ' g . . _
/ / ' 1‘ j a - . ._ '
/ ‘,’-’.', ‘ ‘ I,
.7 ‘5 (JV,
1' \X/ L, N) L, .,» ," . ' ‘4. i: 2;
“I I I L / > ‘ \ ‘ '1 . ' I
\y‘ 6" \'i‘ x. t ‘ [I \ ( ._ u if) ..,
~ \
f
' ,c . ’,'/4 w,
i " ‘ ' -" \ C“ -- ////:..
I {7 ‘-~ . it (. u \‘, (N.. X Y
vi N?! m x . V
g7 / IN [A
r / .'1 , “(I ,1
O
q / // x? 7
r) " O I \> / / x , ,,,

 V / I , ‘ 3 " 1 .n _ . /
/ (If, 'F / t“ ' ///"~._/ / , . . .1 ,‘ x: 1 .,‘] _
v / / /"‘l/ ' ’ »“' ,7 3 .
\, ,‘,/p, i /V/ 5 /
.67 |
I" \‘ ' k >7 ; J
. ”2,. v I. v T 5..-"~er \\y f l '
,', . \\. ' {1 >1 2 - J// 1. y/ "fir; h 'V/
g 0 «give; [to if ‘r J/I/P‘r’m‘} if"; /Q.x‘vg/
/T‘-\
v p y r, a f
'3/ ‘W‘Z'aA {j : t' \ i ' ,' , .-
’, ‘ ' ,). ,‘
I w ,‘. J ‘ \ I p
as," l , ’,/;’ ’51; , ,>‘ : " v, ,d ‘ ,- ; 7a

 . / fl
\ ’ ...

\(‘\ r l; \ I!
, , ("7" “I

’Ij- \x\. , 7 IL a _

,\\\\ ‘.‘
\\. a.“
\x‘x.

 ‘r .
Breathitt Circuit Court.
Clyde Dale, Admr. Ioren Smith, ”laintiff.
—vs- 1.331301711313111“. oi” AUTHOPITIES.
Lexington e Eastern ?ailwav Comoany, Defendant.

I Blankenship’s Admr. v. Horfolk E Teetern Ty. 00., 14W Ky. 260, z '
s.o. 145 s. w. 995. ’
Koke's Admr. v. Andrews Ft~e1 Co., 149 Ky. 627; s.c. 149 S. T.

968. (Furnace boy caught between cars.)
Aerkfetz v. Humphreys, Recr. oi Rabesh Railroad, 145 U. S. 418—421.

(Cited in many cases. See Dig. U. 5. Sup. Ct. Reps. (1--206),
Vol.4, p.5970.) L//

Jones 2. Qii&}?°"1%9 S. i. 951; (fiection-man%uni:5.€fd. Emps. 1
Liabilitym‘b) ”W . ., U V l ,

, , . /
,1 fa. a. o. By. Co. vs. Barnes's Admin, 15:2 Ky. ’7538; 8.0. 117 s. i/
fig 261, and, onsecond aypeel, Barnes‘. Admr. vs. C. &.0. By. Co.,

1 147 Ky. 805, 8.0. 145 S. W. 1115. (Kember of wrecking crew on

track, not in line of duty, a mere tresspasser, notwithstand-

‘ ing feet he was at time an embloyee.)

C. H. O. & T. P. fly. Co. vs. Troxell, 157 S. W. 545. (A water-boy

injured in Somerset-Ferguson Yards. At time engaged in line of

his duty, and reasonably necessary for him to cross track.)

C. N. O. & T. P. By. 60. vs. McElroy, 146 Ky. 668; s.c. 142 S.W.
1009. (Where cinderpathe in yards maintained, look-out must be
kept.7 '

‘4 c. 1:. o. a: w. 1?. By. 00. v. Reynolds' Admr., 102 3.1.1.888. (0.11.)
(Same case, on second appeal) Beyflolds's Admr. v. C. N. O. &
T. 1‘». By. Co., 148 1:;. 252; s.c. 146 s, E. 416. (0.11.)
Helton'sAdmr. v. c. e o. Ry. 0:.,157 Ky. 580; 5.0. 165 3.‘-5r. 224.
'(Cohtrib. Heg. of persons on track precluding recoverya) (Excellent)

 .._ . , . j 1 ‘J a . . " > ‘ .
. - Q . , .
: .1 ' ' ‘ I’I . I _ > ' I I , ‘ > , ', >
; _ . I - x . .' ;Jafiuarg121,'1915‘1
‘ :3. 33.153arfiz-31fi, an, _ > . ' '_ . _ _
'. .1:oui:.=v§.11e, ..;. » ' . ’ . ‘ I _ * ’ _ I
' _ Eaar Sir: ' ' ’ ‘ . ‘ - 1 " ,' ‘
>.. - 59p13ihg to yum: letter af"tfie 90th inatant, making I
‘ inquiry in regard ta the suit 0f filyfle Bale, Admr. of fioémn 3mi§h
I ” v. L & 8 33.691, lately,triaé in the Bréathitt 31:03:: Smart, I
. ' have to say that at the conclusicn af this trial on Tfiefifiay, » .
' ' January lgth, fihe juxg refiurned a vezfiict far tfia fatal sum of I
I #5.EQQ¢OO, digtribnted as fallomg, viz: ~ . 1. ‘. V
I I . $4,000.00 to flag Smith, the infgut flaughter. ' 1‘
‘ ,. _ ‘ $1,009.00 £0 the yeanger sons. - I _ . I
1 I f. ‘ 750.Q0'to.fihe glfier son, anfi" _ ‘ . > '.
' , '.7-$0.90 to 38513.0 Smith. thé warm...
_ . 51 vThe verdiet i9 more thaa.twice as mnch a3 it annula have ‘
> K? i haen under the evidenau, or axg‘fair’ayulicatiom of the evidefiee.
> _2. . . . .,
‘ 0f gourse, it wag awaraei in purauance of an instxustion giyefiquon '
' thé theory thfifi the came was a 0&9? fifiier.fiho Foaernl IflWw iang -
' “ Opiaion, fihe yréof offeréfl by'fihe'nlaihfiifif fairly sustainufi €333 . .
. “ 19iew? '.1 ‘ 7" . ' » .' IE
1 . ' fig-firm afinvietian ES aunt the séaa is yeversib15;'zThéré
_ i§.no chance 0f aur obiainigg a uaw firiul‘in_fihe*10wer cgurtmriflé;"
. ’ morainglg, hefure I left Jaflkson, I prepare& Hatian‘ané firafinQaifar . _
, a nflw trial.'fiuak an 0369: giving time unfiil the next farfi‘tg Egg- -
gar; aufi teufier Bill G5 Excentigfie,‘mnfi aifie an erfiar fii?evt1flg\%he
.' , Official Sfifnographer ta make aha £319 fihe‘uauaI trangerimt fifW$fi§\‘ I
_.Gvijagca. It tha mama time, I prep&reé a araft of 93? Bill Of ; 1:1‘ .
- _ Eficeptiuhé,to be perfeetéfi,1at§§e . ¢ . 1' 1 1' _ ~ ’.1 ' {i}
. > - . * . . ‘ . . ~ . ‘ g. ‘
, , ’ -* . » . ' ‘ . ‘ r ".

 ' 6* Unions Ifam very much deceived, the‘reeord ie rank '1 ‘
» ,eitb errors. ‘SeVeral serione errorg were committed by the Court .
‘Efimtfiejnghingunn of the blendings. After the trial had begun I
L' ‘nnfi the nlnintiff was introducing his proof, at one stage of the n 1
' proeeedinge, he offefed proof in tognrfl tb the men of the Sackfion "
V yarafi and firi‘fixflJZS-K 313 ‘6; £13551; 13,2; 031' the garndfi‘azl Lsnblig. To 1; *Jr, we
. -‘L I objeoted enfi the Court at iiret eu$tninet an; objection and 3e#, I
. ‘ ~ clinefi to admit the evifienec. lite? on, the aluiutiff Jenewefl his
I . . effort to'ihtroduen thi§.efidenoe and over on: enrueet bbjeotion E
the Cnnrt afimittefltit. at thin built, we yreyarod and iiicfl an * E
' fiffidavit alleging egrprise and noveq the Sourt to wet afiide the '
- sweating of the er3 and continve the ease. Edie motion wag nver— ‘
E rutad.>vfin juiament ie tbet the intrannotion oi thin evidence was. .
Irrerrwneous tor the region thnt no dawn; had been rained by the ’A
' . blendtnge reeneeting the ume of the'yards or traoka by pedeetriens .
, and, as plaintiff had hpeoified the grounds oi nogligende, it was 1 I
fl:,onr contention that he Bhouid be restrieted t0 the ebéoiflo grounds_
: nlléged. ‘ ' ' ' . E ‘\ n
. ' at the eloeegof nlaintiff'e’froof, we argued at eoneider« ’
' ' . able length in support of on: motion for a pexemytery inetrucfion,
_‘ relying for the moat gnrt on the gggeption recognized in_the John—
eon cane (lately do ided}, and_n1no Upon the deeinion in the Blank-
. enehip Ghee, reinforced b; the denied cane, the Uonniff case, and .
‘ othereiof'thht olden. nt the conelneion of the argument, Judge 1
_ Ki dell dolled upon Mr. Harding to enever hume29f the propositions ’_.
. we had contended (of and, nitex tfietonjng to him for.ub0fit twenty
' minutes, stated that hie grammnnt did not meet the propositions for _
‘ ' . 31.1111le Iwe had. contended, but, in the Same- breath, announced thatthev . I

 . ' ‘ BTIM ' ” ' ’ " 1/‘21/15.’ '
. ' _ would overrule the motion. The procf was clear and positive ass
3 .., , , . . , , .
. i to the nature of Emith's employment. He was shown to have been _ '
‘ l -g a trachawalher and tender of switch~lamps in the Jackson yards.‘ .
. : his duties as track~walher were fully explained and, so far as,1 ‘
' CQUld see, there was practically dc Jiffercace'hetwcen his fifl~ ’
' pin ment ma! d1" “ti 6; 't-"zier-i;ui:(‘ze;? and the emglcyvxsgit ij‘ng’ duties of
i 1 ‘ ' Efis‘!.ain,ker,ef:‘iiin). - I ‘ ~ » - 3 V _-
.‘ g . ‘. C, - 35‘s.? the dei’s‘znddnt, we ihti'trluaj132:“? 35.22»; “."ii‘ermzi and. 'E-liaginser
‘ - of the intra and the erciaa and yigihrcr cf second flu. 10, and
I -‘ p the 51:: ":;:-jiffzi'eu of 7"".a7..‘:futt:.::, ‘07., .53.‘ the bin:’..';rruan 1.} :5" th e lintitra,
i . 7 I .ha 5V3iifiad ts having given Lwith'ciurcrs notice, shcgtlyphefere a
_ the accident, of the inst that See a: so. 13 was going to has? down.
,_ {:-3 min. €‘;:::".(;.§:. . 151' .1 I this 39k1(}«331‘531‘51-fif:lL-fii’i and, 1’10 at?
S i ' . ' . '
_ ("23‘s. {.1 range to i*‘*;':z':.~i:-c‘:y_ '.‘Eattrfr. _ l - . l
- ‘.' it; the 217.30.“? 13.1"". ‘£:;‘;‘:_i:‘% 55.-Vanna, :11 tit. cj.:.-fu:"-r-: ,0? [the case,
. ‘1 7:.-1a twain =-,»=;m-*.::‘, the Court Ci ::- gw;:.:'=:'=:'3;‘:tcry lifi‘fiffziihfti1377., urging ‘.
_, - . hi, tiuit Whatwmr 4?.‘a7'f:_:y‘ the defer-(tent have "932.031 1.3115 e3: with»
- » reference t< having a lookout or wirinj‘mnsice or warning of the T
actnment of Second do. 10, ei~uith reference to having this train ,
, , under‘contrcl, that it was relieved from these things by reason
. ' cf the erpress notice and Warning given to Smith.by Hatter. Ida
further argued that the proof conclusively shoWed that Smith’s inn
juries wereidue entirely to his own negligence and sure in no way, ‘
\» l ‘ , ,,,
attributable to negligence 0A the part of the defendant. It was
, f’ asparent at this stage of the trial that the Court had made up his
».. mind to let the case go to the jury,whcther or no,and as it was ,
3 . submitted. I V - y ' _
. I , I have every confidence that the Court's instructions, ,

 1.. ‘ > , I “
, . ‘1, 3,.. _ ' V . -‘
13.3).” .174. . 1/21/15.
’ ‘ . ,I, t I ‘ .' - . V . A » . .. V.‘ A. ‘ ’.‘. _
each and all of which were glnea at the instance of the pluihullf, .
' 1. m, ... . 1 - 1 'r,. g 1.1.5- '3 ..
more e410ueons. E0: the éoiandant, we 03¢wred a long LiSt of
‘ A » ._‘ .-. .—_I .I. ‘~- I — fi '
lh8tffl0ti0n8 coveiinfi the variaus phases of tnn cage, but none of
-"‘ “ ' 171. ‘I. ~ ' ~sz \ , .'»-'.» ~ " . a 1'" . ' «Jr — - ;'.-r w I " v
7.21: 13h. III-I3. o ;21 74 cm, :33. the 00111 t . JIM-7 £30311 (1 Ilia. not Sufi-T mayfihlng
,-'”"“k " . - »I
:’r } I. J.. . ., " . .Ium M... '. _I I . I -. ..~ ..-.. .1. ,.. .«L ., -113»,
;4; «H Lava: mount gVfihhua risk; snld ludhlmg h$vhu the u33ect of Hat~
{55% ter's notice to Smith u¢on ihv ivfi: sf imith #0 ha mg Mia fiuurfi anfi
W" '/ V
1"' I + 1‘4; no .‘1 --:-‘ .I I q a J- : m («I-v7 n “M‘— . »-.<.-I's.-.:,1~: 3_.», 3r. «I «w m n . ,I I1, ,, A .
1w. 0 “:7.: ; 1.I. .'ui.;,.,., 7.)). «I,I,» 75,0 ..1; x57...‘ L _ . 0.31.; n. .J.I J. I. .1 J .L. uh I; Int/[.47 (If, flu , I
‘ 9316 ugthifia w? fiqvef an is thr ery’of QIItH tu hiva a cage by ’
I Q ‘ -
3v
lOCEinr fir listemingintc. n}"n he T?CV?Ҥ irex : yiatw 3f CFfOty ,
ifi thv clear befiquu ;hn fi: 331 Egyn ihw "fiilc'nf fikr main track
/ . _
‘ 7 11:017. 7 53:30}: in 'I?: 5213113332, ii!) if)" (':‘? J57? L 7;" L'izfit-m“: ‘.1-’(;-1‘€2 Qt he}:
filiriifi fififvafifi, bafih in whui 212 Court ustué‘lg wriC is fihm'jury
7 '.:.Vrfiri 1I,-7:111? if“ (3151": " t m“ to 9 :7:! ‘:‘,c {fr-::': ;ff “ - ' ‘ ’
" , - I am natiafirfi {hat 1% i: not were Optifiifim an my parfi
thuh iflfiutow the Eoiifif thnt Y3 verb 3111138 entitlui $0 a per-
', wmwtgty inatymatian at the clear of the nlmfififiiff‘m testimony
‘ anfl even MOSS Ulfiinlv nutit1m6 be such an iuctructiuu at the 01036
Of the uflolm cave. ”hn‘hnr Lhe f atfithnt Juige $1 8011 18 an a3-
.1, .r- . ,N ,,.},Y ‘_-,:. "(.3 - . mun“. . . .2‘. ., I. “.,.2. :..
,=_t1'.‘1;'i$u .LOI.‘ f “€37MIII;.1.DI~.1 L:.«Tb‘: u: 3 DE: 73 01.7.1111}. .347); v’Ohud/ n1.-..’I3.C.1 I-ulj £17,131»? {:0
-I 7' .‘; 1 4. , ,. ‘ : ..‘.~ ~ .. ~ 1 ‘ .. , .:. '2, . . "I. .7. ~
do Wlufl n33 vatlun in Lbjm LyimL, E L0 nan wnam, on» all 03 usfi I I
. . apixx . + ' 1 - '
' presume, %fiafi:at Elberty “0 &ram our own coucIu31onm.
T "‘ -~" ‘~' qw— ”».‘”- -‘ ._., ‘ -"'-'§ " a 3 .,. N" I? ,n ~.. .- r' o f 3"") (IL-"c: ’.I 7} my“: ‘I'E' .I '
.._ .A‘-.‘.1.; b In”); 7.x; ‘ ,LJ. u ‘L :‘VLti _Lil. 9713.0 Leigh) J..: P uan.I.x:I.).- (‘..-.ILJZI