xt73bk16mf8w_702 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/mets.xml https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14.dao.xml unknown 35 Cubic Feet 77 boxes archival material 51w14 English University of Kentucky Copyright has not been assigned to the University of Kentucky.  Contact the Special Collections Research Center for information regarding rights and use of this collection. Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company and Lexington and Eastern Railway Company records Railroads -- Appalachian Region -- History. Railroads -- Kentucky -- History. [541] G.W. Hobbs v. L&N, Wolfe Circuit Court text [541] G.W. Hobbs v. L&N, Wolfe Circuit Court 2016 https://exploreuk.uky.edu/dips/xt73bk16mf8w/data/51w14/Box_64/Folder_7/9604.pdf section false xt73bk16mf8w_702 xt73bk16mf8w "\
mu. . S AL} . . ., . ”If; _v "
L I; 1'. .'; Z _ r. . ,
Kw A ’_
t .
Vol. 170—‘—No. 2 .. 1 2‘ ' P. 161—320
DECEMBER 2, 1914
NATIONAL REPORTER SYSTEM [ AMERICAN DIGEST SYSTEM é
(Every Case Reported) ‘ (Every Case Digested) i ;'
ATLANTIC NORTHEASTERN “Annotated “)4 CENTURY DIGEST (1658-1896) 3 i
FEDERAL NORTHWESTERN I DECENNIAL DIGEST (1897-1906) ' §
PACIFIC SOUTHEASTERN J ‘ AMERICAN DIGEST(Key-No. Series) 1i
SOUTHERN SOUTHWESTERN l MO‘Q'I‘HLY DIGESTS (to date) I i
(U.S.) SUPREME N. Y. SUPPLEMENT L REPORTER DIGESTS :.
ONE CASE A KEY TO ALL CASES f
_h _j—Tfig’ "“‘—V 7" E:L,‘::—if:._-— i
. . g
A New EdItlon of .
° ’ L D° ° ry
Bouvner s aw Ictlona
. C
and Conmse Encyclopedla
See back cover page '
WEST PUBLISHING CO. ‘
ST. PAUL, MINN.
ubncrlptlon Prlce, payable in advance, $5 a year; Including binding and :
dellvery of bound volumes, $4 a volume. single number. 25o ouch. ,

 If the Courts have been called
upon to define a word or phrase
Stnee 1904 you wzll find that
definition here
:14; _ ,7, r; , '3) ., ,..,,_r:\
// _ I“ I \‘x
- »..,,, _._,zt— 22:5-33““: use, :§'_/_*~~-:.u A A
Four E3 _ " i , f 3% Supple-
"011111188 gig: ’:gfl/nglégrggzr . menting
BUCI'PHH wig.“ wagons wofinfi‘fi—Iilwiys «L but not
’ ‘ ‘ _Eimgrgis? f Films 2:: mfisw‘imgrggsi
binding 3 m «m, sn perseding‘
may; “in“ Page“; ”We: _ V
5381 pages ; ‘ '3 g; ‘ ' Words &
Thin paper I m .ej'ii'fffir- Phrases
$24.00 "ii”? '.;. ¥f_'§n:~:"=. First
delivered £1.33 333333; ‘3‘-2% Series
W ORDS 81 PHRASES
I T
SECOND SERIES
:mog:
WEST PUBLISHING (30., St. Paul, Minnesota.
Gentlemen: You may send me, on acceptance of [his
order, a set of ‘Vords & Phrasesa Second Series, in 4'1: vol-
umes, bound in buekram, at $244.00 delivered.
Address , . .. i
(1mm

 Ky.) CiliiSAi’iiAlil-I s; 0. KY. co. v. DEAN 1137
will present its demands against, the 1l11< train. She had a hahy 19 months old and
t'endants in one pleading. in su1-h form as 111 was in a 1i1-li11al111-on1iition. \\'h11n the train
render definite and vertain the items of its‘vanie, and they left the waiting room if) 74'“
1-laim against the d11f1ai1lant or defendants, 1 to it, they passed the 1'11111lu1-tor11n 1l11- plat-
and on whieh the issues may he furined.1'orm, Dean. who had the hahy in his arms.
){iwlx'els \'. Collins, .158 Ky. 117, 16% S. W. it\§.liol1l the 1-onrl111-tor that he wished to 1:11 11:1
Reversed. the train nith his daimhter to tarry thn hair-1'
——"——“—‘ on for 111-1'. The 1:1.1111l111 tor said. “All right."
:11:1l\1.'1-11i1111. {they went, first to iii1'1i1:l<1i{ 11111}
CHESAPEAKE & 0. KY. ('30. v. Dl-IAN. 111' 1111. 111111.19 11:11" 111111 “1.1-._., 1.1111 then 11, 14., > 1
(Court of Appeals of iientin-lm'. Nov. 11!). 1'11 the front 1111i. This they did. .-‘.. ‘111;.
191‘“ Who Was ('.’il‘l‘jiillli .‘.ira i'iiihfs: \‘alise, went
. 1..-\111111111. Am» lhazoi: 1§ .lmltli')filli:\'1I-:\‘1'—« in first. .\lrs. Kin: foll11'11.'1~1l him. and 111.1!»:
.u 1' ..,. »1 31.1 . 1 .
.'_ ill" ‘- {"3“ “1 f 1331-. _ . . ‘the iii-st seat that was \‘al'dlli. zles‘ 1:111111'
1, inal‘, the \reluht ot the, e‘videnee is ‘1‘51ihi 1. 11 , 1.11 1 _; 1 ti 1.] , 1, 1" 1 1_1.
' defendant does not .llls’tif)‘ the Hunt of .\11-1 111..1 “H 1"‘\“i" .i‘ ‘1“.‘1 11”“1“ 1‘11 17:111.
heals in rewrsing a ,i111l1;1:11111t for plaintiff, 1111—1111 111-1'. and JInhiwllaieH started out. ‘1'» 1.1 :1
less the \‘erdiwt is [iaihahiy ii‘.'.'ilill.\‘t thy- 111'11l1-n1'e. i 1111 ::111' 11:, 111.. 1,11111'1111111 111,1. 1min was in 3111,.
,,H‘d' 43‘3””“3 ‘_"1' “_1.11‘.‘}',."il-"1‘f1ff" '\'i’i“":."“‘i 1 H1111. and as he was fJ'Iil1tj (i11Wll the sit-111.1111
surror. tent. lhg'. m ”11.15 ”U111; Dee. 1‘15. 9,; .1 .. _ ‘lln ’_.. . 1‘ .1" __ '..
1111,3411] itiam ...ixe .1 ~~111 11.1 1.11». \.1111.i t.i1-1.1 hm.
, .. ... 1" : 1 11m” ' .- l: [1'1 111116111":
2. (,.\l:l:tl‘IlIS 1§ .3:]:1)#Ae1rro.\‘s FOB iNvlCllIl‘Si 11L ”.‘ H, "1 "‘1 ”1' 1111-1111, 1’, ' ‘ “1 1
—~iNs’i‘nl‘1"i‘i(1.\s. 1i'(\21(}111il§,\' shoulder and 111,1111'1112his arm.
in an aetion for injuries sustained in} ilis t11siii1111ny :1.»; to what 11111 iii'i'wd 1111:1‘1‘1-1111
“with!“ ””1“ :ntram, l.‘”””‘]“‘““. that] 111him and the 1111n=i121"111r and his 122111111213'
“10>“ lli 1-h:11'1_1'e oi the tram iiiiti lltlilW‘Ii I‘i‘1til1-11-1111r ‘1 111-1r i1 _ 1.1i1-11111lr1l ‘ 111"i111n'
plainiiif was 211iiie'11111'ni it to assist, his dangle. ‘:" f‘ I! [L “‘ :.....11, i» ‘ 1k "’1 ‘”’ »‘
ter thereon. and that he had no intention of «vi. his (ML-,1 1:1‘1'. .‘~il':¢. 11.11:}; till the wile-r
taking 1:1.-'.~1:1::11I111n the traini and it‘_tl1.1_1lt‘ram 1111111 11.11 2,11,.11' 1‘11 (111; 11111111143111 '1" 111 111.-
\\'as biiill'ié‘t Wile 111 was 1.1mm: 1: wit-11111: M. 1,. .. vb 1, 1, ,1 ... ,1
girinl him a reasonable opportunity to ali'flii ‘3‘? [MIL 11} ”‘“.” ““th .Hh' LN"? ‘7 “1
(11111111111111. and as a 1iir1'1't resilit of this 11.11“”. 1117““ it? 11111? nannies; 13“”7 “if ”3121 “t.“
was inilired, to tind for him, but that \lnivss tl111‘s1111 the (,‘1rl1liil1‘iill'. 111' say anything to him:
jury 1111l1ered from the 111::1111111'11 that 1111- i";itll and that “.1'“! he (“we out 1.11: the ...1]. 11,.
was started \\'li'il1>llt \‘.':lli,ill:' at the station ‘1111- $111.“; ,1, ..1 11 . ...,W ., ,,1 , 1. )1, [1,.1. 1
usual 111121.11 of time, and that, those in 1:112:11“ ““ fl" ‘.”m“ I ll Mi" “1‘ I.“ 1111‘ 11. M
of it: knew that plaintiff was in the 311: 111' iii“ 111:1.l11'rm. zllni win-n he attempted to stun
alightinu', to find for defendant, were not er-ioj'L‘ with the other foot: he struvl; one
1'”[’““’l”51\v F 1 ‘4 _ it'out a::ai11si, the other, and. was thus thrown
l1l1. . ot'r1.*1or otter eases. see arriers.1 ' . ,1 - . .. . . a . .1
. . ... . - .1\‘. 1'1. .“111. .- A
1 11111. 1111.1, 51 1:47, 1.,;1_,-].:.,,1i, 1.14.5. Dee. 111;. 1‘ [‘1” 1,1“ 3‘ ‘3. “‘ “1"“ ‘.‘“ .‘.,.N.‘. 1 ”I,"
5 33151:} ‘liiiitt’ii, 111nn1l fur the 111aintih. t1:-;n1;_1' '111;»
:;. (.‘..innnzns (§ .‘lilfl‘i/J—anwry r111: TNJU— damages 2’11 57'1““. The 11111111: UHU‘FM ind-4*
nlizs Si‘s'un'izo 1N Amuirrrwi mam Tl:.\l'_\' ‘ ment on the \‘11rdi1-t. and refused a new trial.
4C0N'l'iillll'l‘0ll1‘ NEGLIUENLE. 1 ' 11111. 11111‘1.111_1;1_1111 ”1.1.1.1115.‘
A Herson who steps from a Smr-nn'n‘in: r- 1 1' , ‘ . , ‘
.' ‘2 .. . . ' .1.-..-- -111 1 ‘1- “.3;
train and is nuured is not, as a ll’lili'tt‘l‘ oi law _ H1] '“le L” djlf’k‘md 1L} “I. ”1.1 1 m”: H
guilty 11.1“ 1-01111-ji,11111py 11121111111.“ 11,111 may “1. is taat the \‘erdn-t is against. ernlenre. the
cover if his conduct In so doing; IS thatfif an ‘ Weight 111' the eridenee is with the defendant.
ordinarily prudent man under the eireunrlh11E we cannot say that the verdiet is 1mi—
stances. 1 ~ inihlv 1111-1i1ist the evident-e & iarr trial is
[E1]. Note.~i1‘or other eases. see (arrn‘l‘syi ‘ " ‘”‘ " 7' 1 .‘ ‘. ‘ , " ‘
(tent. Dig. §§ 1315.], 12:313., 1153—13117; Dog 1 guaranteed lr)‘ the ( onstltution it} this 1-lass
ing. § 2:21.353] [of «Jases. and the right, to a jury trial wani'l
. . . he. of little value, if the verdiets of iini1s
A1111; 'rom ‘ireint Court Franklin ' . .' ‘ . '
‘ l" L 11 I C ’ were disturbed snnply heeause the Jury cred—
(..onnt-y. . ‘ 1ited one set of witnesses rather than an1 ‘
Aetion by John Dean against the Chesa- other ‘
pealie & Ohio Railway (‘,mnpany. From a. ' .
_. . . _ 1‘ [2] We do not see that there was any
Judgment LOL‘ plaintitt, detendant appeals. . . . 7‘ .
. substantial error 111 the instructions of the
Athrmed. . ,1 .
court to the _]lll‘_\’. the court, 1n subs-tame
Shelby, NOI'thC’Utt & 511011).“ 0f LBXHIYJEOIL told the jury that it? the defendant’s agent
and Il'll Julian, 0f Fl‘iUlkftJl't, I”? appellant. in charge of the train had notieed that the
SCUM: & HHIHIHOH illld GUY H- Bl'lin'gsy all Of plaintiff was going upon it to assist his
Frankfort, fUI‘ “DUCHCC- daughter thereon, and that he had no inten~
tion of takingr passage on the train, and the
HOBSON, C. J. John Dean brought this train was started while he was leaving it.
Suit to reeover for injuries whieh he received without giving,r him a reasonable opportunity
in alighting from one of the. trains of the to alight therefrom, and as a direvt‘ result
Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company. AC- of this he was injured, they should find for
cording to his testimony the facts were these: him; but that they should find for the de-
lle Went on Fehruary S, lt)l.1, with his fondant unless they believed from the evi-
(ianghter, Mrs. King, to the station at Frank- denee that the train was started without:
fort for the purln‘ise of helping her on tln-in‘aitingr at the station the usual length of
‘For other cases see same topic and section NUMBER in Dec. Dig. & Am. Dig. Key—No. Series 6‘: Rep'r Indexes

 158 170 {<1)11’1‘11\Vi-}S’i'141111\' 111-11’01‘1'1‘1-‘13 (Ky.
, 1111111, 111111 111111 111: 1110 111110 1111- 1111111 511111011 1111-111ion 1.11111 1111‘ 111-1-1-11er-11 111-10111111111: was 11 11:11-
. (111151-111 1-11111'141-111’11' 11111\\\' 11111111.110111111111111 1," 1” 111“ “MW-"i. ”“11 ”V'W‘YUI‘H 1'11””‘1 11." 1110
\\‘11.\' 111 1111‘ 1111 of 11112111111; 11111141110111. ”“‘] ‘15 ("”“'1”:‘1}'1‘ UH 111M Issuu on a

i" "'l 1 _ 1 1 ' l 1 ll 1 t _ SiliiN‘lilli‘lll. 111-1111111 111 111110 1111-‘1111121111-111.

0" A H 11111111111. ‘”'“ ‘9 111111-11 111 11x11. .\1111-. 1111- 11111111' 01151-5, 51-11 3111111111153,
3111101. 1111- Jury. 111 81111511111115 111111: 11' 1111- ppm” 111.; $13, 1111; 7111.13 111:. § 0,151]
11111111111. 111101 1110 min 1111 slurlml, '1111111A . . 1
I . , t. . 11. ,' ‘ .\11111-:11 1111111 (11401111 (1111111. 1’1-1'1'5' (1111111):
1:11'11)’ S1011111-1l Mom 11' Willie 111 11111111111. :11111‘ ‘1 . _ ., . 1 _ . _ 1
1 . . _ 1 7 _ . .1.11111111 115- 1. .1. 1111.0 112111114, 1.. 11.
out 1111' 1111s \\11u.1l 11111 1mm 111-1-11 11111111-1]. ,, . . . 1 . .

. . ,, . . 111'11wus 11111111111~1r111o12< 111 1111111 11 111-1:7
1111-1 s11111111l 111111 11111110 11011111111111. llils 111-1 1 . 7 . 1 ., .
1 .. . V . 11110111 1111-1'1-11111111-1-1111-1'1-11 :1:-::1111:~11 $11111 1.1'11\.'11
>211'u1'111111 wus 111'11111-1'15' 1‘1-111swl. \\11111- 1111-1 . . , 4 .,
. . . . 1111111 111111-1‘s, .1111111111-111 1'0’1'1.'1-11.:111111111111115
11111- 1111111111111-1-11 111 11 1111111111s 111 5111110 <11111-s. , . . . ..
. . . 7 ,1 111111111111s11’111111's 111111-111. .\|111'1111-11.
11 1111.\' 11111, 111-1‘11 111111111011 111 l\1-111u1-l(.\‘. 1110‘ . , 7 .,_.. _ , ,7 .
. V 1. . ‘ , , . N-i‘, 11151», 111 b. \\. _1_‘. _‘.5 my. Luw 1.011.
11110 111 111-111110111 1s 111211 :1 1111151111 \\1111 $111141 “..1 '
. . . . . . . ‘, _I,
11'-111111 slowly 111111111: 11'11111 111111 ls 111_1111‘1-1l 111
11111' 11S 11 111:1111-1' 111‘ 111w guilty 111’ 1-111111-11111.1 W. 11. “1111111 111111 1111x1-1xvo1111 & 1111mm“,
1111'_\' 111-:111:--111‘1‘. 111111 111111 111* l11;1_\' 1'1-1-1w1-1'11111 111' 1,1111111111.1'111'1111111-11111lls. (111-51011111111-
it.‘ 111x 0111111111 111 S11 11111111 is 111111 (11’ 1111 111'11'1— 11133111 .1:11:1{>‘1111, for 11111101100.
11111'111'111‘11-11-111' 1111111 11111111 1111- 1'11'1'111115111111'1N.
'1‘111‘ 1'1'11111 11111)" 111,1 111111111: \‘1-1'3' sl1>\\'l_\'.:1111l 11' N17NX. J- ”11 April ‘1- 1111151. 1110 1‘11‘111'119-01
111111 501-111 111 111) 1-11111'1-11' $1110 111 :<11-]1 1:1'f_11‘. .1. 1.111112 1111-11 :1 11111111- 111111 1-1111-1'1-11 1111)-
3'1-0 111S111111 v. 1. (‘. 11:1111'111111 (‘11.. 77 S_ \\fliiiou 1111-1'1-1111 111 1111- 1‘1-1‘1‘1' Circuit 0111111 111
11111:), ‘_‘3 1(1; T111w 111-o 1:11:71; 19111-11 ‘3 1';1_!1111\‘11- 11 1111121111111 1'1-\i\'1-11 11'.‘11111.‘1-11. 111111 \\"1111-11 1111111111111;
\\':1.\' Co., 110 S. \V. 3771. :1:; Ky. 1111w 1:1-11.111115 1'01'111'131'1-11 11y 11111101100. 11111112, 111111 011-
515V. 11011-11 111 111111 1111111 111 Mun-11. 111117, 1101111151:

\\‘11110 11111 111,21'1'111‘111111 on C111111‘i11uto1-y 11113. 1 1\1'--l1 (,'111'111-‘11. (1. H. 111-own, 111111 1111; 1.-.\1-1-u1oI.'
1121-1111- 1111::111. 111110 111-1111 1111’11'1- s111-1'11'11: 1111-1Hf “111-11111111101113 T” 11‘-15‘ ““11““ 111111 Ill”—
111-1'1-1111:1111: 11111 11111 11s1< 1111:. 111111 \\'1- 1110 8111-1111111 1'0 I'U‘ViVU 1110 .llliif—TUIL'HI', BFUWIIF‘ 1111111111-
111111-11 111111 1111- 1111-111 111’ 1111- huh-110111111 in 111) 15111111115 111-111111'1'011, 111111, 111111 1101113.; overrul-
w11y 111101-1011 1111- 1'1's11115, 1111110 111111. 011. 11103' 111011 1111 11119101: 'J‘110 lower court

J111lg11111nt 111111111011. 5115111111011 111-111111101" to 11113 1111swe1' 111111 1'1-\‘i\'-

011 1110ju-i:u10ut. G. 11. Brown‘s 11111111111511'11—
‘_g 11115 1111110111.
7 7 \ The, :111swer 1'155131101l 1111'00 reasons why 1119
1 1 v 1 . . 1 v ‘ _ . ¥

1'1“)“ “ ‘\ 11101113 V' LYl FLU- ]111121110111 5111111111 11111 110 1'01‘1V01l: (11 1.011111%
(Court of 1111110111.; 111' 1(1-11111cky. Nov, 10, 1111110, 111111 no 1111131051 in it: (,'_’) 1100111150, 51111113
“Hi-1 1111- 1‘11111111iou of 1110 .1111_l_‘_'1111*|11, 1111- 05111111 of
1‘ I‘.-11111115 (§ 511:1, l-LAlxl-nsp_AggmMng— I Vim-(1111" 11111-0111;r 111111 fully x1111s1i0111111101111111;
(‘0111-1 1'11ox'1s111’w. 1111111 131 1100111150 1110 judguu-ut 11101111113; 111e-
‘ - "v 1 1 n. " .1 .»1 vi ~ - - . - .1 -
111111111 LL11}. (11111, 1’11111. ..3, 15, 11111111HIE Ell-4111111111111 1s V0111, 111111 the 0111150 01 111-111111 is

Cry 11011111 1) 11- [11115011111111 111 11-1111111011' 101 _ . _, 1 - -_ ,- n 1
1'1-111 1111111 111 11111-1051, 111111 51-1-111111 '_’11. 111‘11'1i1l-‘m'm “1.1”“ 1)) 11111111111011. 1110 1114:1111‘111‘.
111:: 111111. if 1110 right: of 1:111.- 111111111111 111- :1.\'\’1F;11'i“~u'\' 011111111111 to DC \‘11111 1111' 1110 111111.111”! WH-
1-11 111-11111111: 1110 11.111.11.111. 1110 111-111111 111:1;1' 110 1-1111-1so11 111111 G. 11. Brown. the 110110-11-111. 111111
““”‘“ 1” 1’1“.”11‘” ‘ “””‘“- "1' .”1“ "“‘”"t 11111.1 1 111-101' 111-011 501-1011 with suuuuous. 111‘ 011101011
111111w 1,1111 11s512111-1- to 111- sul1s1111111-11 us' 111:1111-1 .‘ ‘ . . _ . . 1- _
1111': 111111 1111 :111>:\\'1-1' 1,11 :1 11111111111 1o 1'1-viv1x 111111” 1111111'11111111‘1‘. “1 01111111130111111 1111111111), ”1
ju1121111-111'. \\‘1111-11 1111-11-13} n111-11-.\ 1111 115512111111-111 ‘ “11111111135011 1111." 0110 10 Ullll‘l' 1‘13 11111111111'111109.
113' 1110 111111111111 :11‘11‘1‘ 11111 111-111111 1111111110111-1-11. |1] ‘1, \Vilil1'111‘01‘011110t1)1110111'stg1'1)111111.1110

1' 1- -- -‘ 1- ~1' 1'~1' 1 1- . . . ,
‘.””.‘MIL :1“) ”""‘,”1‘“ ”f 111111111111 .1“ U” dL 1111sw01‘ 11\‘01's 11121t 111 191111 1111110 511111 111111
10111111111. is not 11 111-1011;11- tn £1111 11111111111. , . . . . . .

1 v 1 ,. - . 11'1111.~11-1'1'1-11 1111 1115 11111-1051 111 11113 31111341110111;
|J1.1l. Bonn—1'01-111111-1~0:1:<0s,S130 1111‘111-sy C0111. ‘ , . ) , ~1 » 7 ,
Dig. §§ 5111.514! 113,3; 1101:. 1111;. § 51.111 10 11101111111111-111111111-11113 111111111111), 11111111111t

'.- 1"‘1':'-1 '31 11':: --
2' JUDGMENT (S 1515.5")—11ELEASE—.101NT TORT— \‘11110 11111 111111 1111 ‘111113 111111111) 111» 111111
1111mm,“- 1111,- :1110 owucr. ’1110 1111113011 51110 111-111111011
“111-1'0 1111111111113 I'CCO\'1_‘1'(‘(1 11 judgmout 1111110 1111111 :1 \‘13111' 1101’111'0 1110 '111lg1111-11t \\"2IS
.‘.‘. 1.N 1W...'.1'1 1,1 ,.‘ . . . .
1‘9“]11511. 1‘11“}. [‘1‘-‘1"1-7‘151 :1 5&111-‘11‘111111'11 “”‘ 10' 01111-1011. ’11115 1110111111 10 ]‘(‘\'1\'C ls 1111 1111111111
1*:15’1‘ 1)’ 11‘ Jill 2111(‘11' 112211115 (1111' 11 11'111, 111)‘ - 4,. ‘ ‘ ,. - , _ V1 .
- ~ ~ 1 .1 >.1--.-1,‘. 1',
1111 1111101111 01 111111111. 11110—111111: of 11111 111111111111 of “1111111111“ “1‘0 \11111, .“1-”$1 ”11.1181 15W!“
11111 ju11;1111-111z, 11mm not 1111011111- 115 11 011111111010 15 01 ”10 (“‘19 113‘1””CS 111111 (El-013' 31111011
5:11'131‘111-111111 of 1110 whole ju11-_-_1 11-111, 01' 11s a must 110. 111-115110111011 iu the 11111110 01’ the 1'0111
1"” 1" ”If 1-1,-1-0v1‘1‘y “””‘ t1““"'1“"'“~ 11111'1y iu i111’01'0st.” \Vlu-u 11111011 111 11111111110-

‘iIM- §"t"’.‘_1¢:‘.‘f ”HWY “1.50"“. 5‘7}: .'..T1111g1111111t, 111111 with 500111111 20. 500111111 18 1111-11115 111111:

(0111. 111:. k 111111; Dec. 1111:. § 555.1] 7 . . . . .
.) ~ Q 1‘ 1'“ G _ . . 1-‘1'01'1‘ 110111111 must 11011141111101] 111' 01111111111111-1-11
.1, Monone (141 )— ONLLUblll‘-\1¥>h’JUDG’ in 1111,- 11111110 111’ the 10:11 party in 1111‘1-1‘11s11.
)11£.\'1‘ ()N Mollox. q 1' "11
\\11111'0 1111 1111sw111' 11y 111111111115111111115 to a ‘1“ 1”” ~ "13*"
motion 111 1'1,-\'i\'11 111 11111 (‘11111'1; 111' ;\11111‘11ls 11 “11 1110 1‘10’111:_11f 1110. 11111111111? be t1'1111sf1-1'1'1-d
j111lg1111-111 1101111151 1111- 05111113 01’ 1.1 111-10111111111: 111- 111' 119s12111-11 11111111;r 1111-. 111-111111111-y of the 111-111111,
11514-1111 1.11111. 1110 1101'1-1111n11t \v11s 1101‘111‘ Sl'l‘YNi wi111 1t 11111.1' 110 0011111111011 111 11m 11111110: 01' 1111‘ 1:11111‘12
51111111111113 111111 111-\'1‘1' \‘oluutul'ily 1111111-111'1-111 1111-, 111:1_\' 11llow 1110 1.11-1’51111 to \\‘1111111 1111-. 11'1111s‘1'1-1' 111'
1:1-111111111.“ ol’ t110 1111111011 to 1'0\'i\'11 was 1111 111]j11« 1lssig111111-11t IS 11111110 to be 511115111111011 in 11113
_.’—._._~—————.———‘i_i.____—___—__-v7._.__.
‘For other cases see same 10pm and section NUMBER 111 Dec. Dig. S: Am. Dig. Key-No. Series & Rep’r Indexes

 Ky.) LOUISVILLE & N. R. CO. v. LAWSON 199
’ ville & Nashville Railroad ("oiiipanv The the air rushed in to fill the vacuum made by
large toe ot,’ his let't. foot and his right foot: the passiil: train. Defendant‘s witnesses tes-
aiid ankle were 'Cl'ltsllt‘tl. Ruin: h_v his father [ titled that: the speed of the train it is Claimed
as liisLiielxt friend. he brought this action t struck pliiliitit'i~ was not greater than S or 10
agains‘ tie railroad eonipaiiy to reeover'niiles an hour The train consisted of an
damages. Fruit-lit: verdict and judgment in engine and about; 3:; ['t'pight ears and it was
his tavor for Moot), the railroad t'UIllpflIly t iiiipossilihx within the short spat-e lying be<
appeals. : tween the «le mt wlier i ‘ ' v' " s' e '

The aeeideiit oeeurrod just inside the liniits ‘ plm-o ot.‘ tilt: illilll't‘f t1; ‘litt:’t:t(:;]llt((114111?) tit:
of Smith's Grove, :iii ineortlorated town of‘ speed of 33 or ::t) miles an hour. These wit-
ahout 800 inhahitants. ‘liet‘emlant's ti'at'lis Iiesses all testitietl that thev hail never heard
1run iioi'tllieart“ and southwest through the ot‘ any live ohieet lit‘illg sueked under a train.
own. am i" resided with his father near The eneine ot‘ the tr-iii " ' '- ' ' ‘

. s ., .. i i “as t'XitllllllL‘ti .it
what is known as "Lawson‘s ('I:ti.\'>‘lll:‘,” some liowlelts. a station north of Smith‘s Grove,
distant-e north ot the depot. ’Jhere was tes— t and {pol-Li “~0ij no marks on it; iiiilieating
tinioiiv to the et't'eet that -i p-itliw-iv :lii)ll"‘til‘lt ‘lIl\' one hot liu ‘ " ' '

. i . i t. . s . i ‘ . . “it >illl(,l\ li} it.
ileteiulaiit s tin-irks north ot its depot and opt [t] lirietly stated. plaintit't mntends that
to the seeond ei'ossiirr ‘llltl\'(‘ was used liv‘thl- rt -o\'irv ii ' ‘ " " '

,. , .i , . - - ltil*l\\“ ,_t “
the residents of the town ot’ \‘niith's (‘i'ove tv ‘I - L U “Hum” ‘h .”‘)l’U “’1'
1' . ,' 11. t 1‘ , I ate iollonin‘: ieasons: the 0\'l(l(‘t!t:e shows
l\'lll:‘ in iat, seetioii :tllt iv others \vlioltiplt- [let'end-int's I‘i"llt '~ * “ ' 4 ~

. . , . , i i , of \\.i\ “as Il\f.‘(l ’1:,
lived three miles north of Sillm’.‘ (”ME I a footpath [iv a large nnnilier of persons with
,‘.. ,,. ‘ . v) .H- _. _ A . .
Jinl‘ie \\ e11 i; .ihput a half dlo/in iliill>tl> iiilth-l; t the knowledge and acttliieStteiice ot the l‘:lll<
see ion o he o\\‘ii near t ie i'ailroat l'l" it o‘ 1mm} conip-iiiv ’l‘li ‘ ' - " ‘
a ‘ . u. e .imident ou-iiiied in an
“..”‘V‘jmd these houses were on l]i:l(.:l(1:lllilztwl]ti]1('tillli‘ii':lt7‘)“1 town. l'laiiititT. therefore. was
sttieeis.1 tili‘lt‘ were side\\'all{s (on these not a ti'estiasser, liiita iit't‘lt>L‘L‘. in approach-
slitttslwtiltilll. t0 the lMHl- '1'I“ it} bitltttl. inz the plave where plaintitt was iiipii'ed, it
1’ Mat It. s .U eount ot the areident is as 101- was the duty of the defendant, to keep a look-
i2t _ t] t‘t ti 1 1' l out and give tiniely warnin'.r of the approach

.a e in ie a eriioon on ie 1 av 0‘ t to in- i of its [I"lill' ‘Ind to - - -' -- - '

_ . . V .. . x. use oioinai; «die in the

inn-1) his lllltltllt‘l‘ sent liiip out to look toli‘ DIS operation of its trains not to injure any onn

a 101'. ivio was expee‘ei to refinrii tome, “':ill’jl‘fl' |.pr j ‘ Writ - ., - ’-'

with a uagon and team. ile went upon (1“— i was”; hinltiaj iixllfilttv 11::51 ‘:i‘ixi) "1 ti‘iiitttemto

ft‘llliflllt/‘S l'i'lht “f Wily Iii 111‘“ ““'tm‘l “1"“-“i”: I keep '1 lookout or to "ive proper si'ai'ils ot‘
.. i h ,_ _ . ,

. ".1.‘ a, r... . . .’. ,‘ ...
“th tit 11> fiktmti Neilltiiiilstaited l‘tunt the, approaeh ot the U‘:llll. though plaiiititt
a oner ie pai iwzzv on tL‘ t’lit :in:s i'i:i o'huu-g pp am not 11.. ~ - - ~ -‘ -

. . . eat the si_n.ils. h: i'tilill.

way. .\t’terw.\lkiiif: south tor swniedisiani'e, t 1p.“- pe \‘.mv the tr-iin qppp.,~1¢hi:prl \L;
.‘.-W ‘, ‘.‘. V.‘ ‘ ‘ .‘ .t , ',: i ‘ a~ A

ii-Ltiili(111il: «((311llll:i>tt11.hlt\;i1)lifl“th\0 (111'*>111.-’-3si:ii:11s were. tlieretore neeessary to apprise

"<‘ t ‘ 1‘ ‘H ' G “I.'-’1 t ‘ 71.3 C “'th liiiii of that whieh lin ali'eadv l'new The
walkinir for the purpose of keeping “':lPllL ‘ stile :ronnd of ne-‘li'renee relied \on is “lit
He then turned and started $011111 for fl1C"1'l. would not lm rr-u-
11‘“ ”“.'W'lw l’illlill'l“ 0f l'i‘l‘l-‘llll'i. l’l‘lllfl Nlllflfi‘d sonnllh‘. hwnuw mosl llkvly wholly 11111101'MI-
unllrr :1 lrnln. Not only so. llul' 1110 only two 1&211'31"
rum-S lhul, hnvo t-vor (‘onn- lwl'oro lho L-onrlS. ; 'l‘hr- (lunur-r of strikingr :1 trrspnssvr is
so l‘ur us \voknow, :11'0lhv(‘:151‘unlh-rronslll—linlinill-ly uroulor lhzln tln- (lflllle‘I‘ ol' lnlur—
prnlion :1111l lhn msn ol' (lrnnoy 1‘1 11.\'. \'. St. 1 in: :1 liwnsl-ls hy surllon. ’l‘1‘v ot1o:;=~_ 1‘. ,. . . ~ . _..fi
possllulny or surh un :1<.-1-nl1-nl. \\ 0 (5011- 1~ .,C‘-‘1”"1‘“‘~-* W “'\'5‘ ’ XMN’N‘L “JU‘W‘W
1‘1 1' ““‘l‘lvv will Q, \" 11‘ L __ ». ‘1' H. (.1.13‘1'111121'111111' ..1-:1':I.1<11:.\'111-17 —— ;\1.11:1111.\1.
“ " “ ‘ ‘5 _‘_1 “'- 111.- 1"" ““1 1 .I‘» 19110.11 Moleo TRAIN — “BEGLICILVL'E r1211
$11110, tho prohuluhly 01 11s orr11rro11rse 1s so SE."
rclnotc thnt, it cunnot he sultl to be {111 urol- ('lrllinurily it is not nogllurnro per so 1111-31
111-111', \vhicll shonhl. in the 1-xorcisy‘ of or11'1— [fuss-hurr to 1111;11t from :1 movlng trnm when 11:
.”. v .. 1.. l1" ... q, ‘hl .. 1. ,- _ [.1 I). ll .\ ‘ 15 tom: at 9111-11 {1 low rule 01‘ speed that It 13
I" -‘ ‘j’ ‘2 L. “‘1" ”‘1 .3 '1“ ““1“ “ . 5 1“” : sale to so alight. but if 1t 15 111ov111:: :1f, :1 splwl
opornllnj; ru1lron0l For other (lt-lnnllons. s00 “ords and Phrases,
:15 to provonl‘ 1111‘11' hour: sucked ulnlrr lho : 1.51.51, :nul scum} $011,... x..g1i._.-..IH.0 lll‘l‘ gm]
._‘. '1'., . _.. . , .,.~'\. ,....M, .. . ~.
t1.11n>. 11“" 1.111111 “‘1" ..nloplul '1 ”‘3 l1l11.1- :2. CAInuIcus lg J.:.."LJ‘(lN'l‘lUlll 111111 Mau-
:1l rule \v1Lh rrspvcl: to Inn-1151.105 on Inn-ks of LICllCNt'l‘LiA 1.11;1r1'1;\11 1“1:<1.\1 Alo\1.\'1: 'l'11.\1.\'.
:1 rnilroml (tonlpnny. Whore. in populous or l’lnintill‘. who stood lipoll thulsnlps “it :1
thh-kly sollh-d ronnnunlllos the trucks :11‘0l“"““ll 1.” ”Ml-w “We ”do” [fluid 1” w‘f‘l'm
. l the tram, “hull was slownru down Io :1llo\\ .11111 .
“5051 by 511911 1211.74“ nnlnhcrs (’1 DENNIS “Mt l to nllu‘ht. and who oxcrrlsml his own .inllunnlnt
1hr prom-111:1), of persons on the trucks 111:1y he l 11nd stoppoll oil in the Llnrk. on (In- sillv of the
'rcnsmnlhly :llllll‘llmtml, we are Connnlllml lo 1 Infill? Ul‘Lll‘ITILLfl “10 I’llilthlll'llll, 111113111‘21‘111111111 klnown -
, . . ~ . ~ .- f"\' 11111 I) l0 llH‘lllll )l‘I‘N .l\' ((' ll'lS. :llll \V 10. Ill
"'1 N‘l\'l‘,') 1;— ‘. .- .
1110 (1111111111. lh M. It 1 H” (111‘ U H“ 111111 1 domg so. stnmhlml and loll llllllk‘l' tho Lruln and
“5' 1””!“1' ““311 "”‘V'll'h‘l‘lH‘T-l 1" 1‘0““ ‘1 I‘M“ \vns iniurvd. \v:1.< 2'11illv of unnrihulory negli-
out, to give \vnrnlngr of 1111- :llllll‘11;1(:11 of {he genre rlvl‘outlng :1 rworory; ‘dllll. in How of such
lrniu, null to huvc tho trnin unllor I‘cusonuhlc ‘3i‘11"1'1!".””5'-V ““:l‘fi‘m‘i‘f' lthel SHMl‘l] sun-1111: ”E
- . . ‘ “: .' ;Q “1 1L“ .‘ ' 1H ' \'1 [TIM
1-onlrol. I. (.‘.. 1:. 1:. (.‘o. \'. Murphys Alhn'r, ‘tllt'(\(t':)l'll?ll‘\:ul$‘ 1‘ 1‘ 1 .. nu “NH )L ‘ l 1
mm '.I-1" r"?1 r—~:1'1"v . ~ M ‘ l 3' . .
l"'rl\-“ ‘5" 'j‘ 5' “" ‘f’l‘."U'l‘\-" I‘d“ I‘LI)‘ Hull. .\otr.~~1